src/HOL/Hilbert_Choice.thy
author wenzelm
Thu, 11 Feb 2010 23:00:22 +0100
changeset 35115 446c5063e4fd
parent 33057 764547b68538
child 35216 7641e8d831d2
permissions -rw-r--r--
modernized translations; formal markup of @{syntax_const} and @{const_syntax}; minor tuning;
Ignore whitespace changes - Everywhere: Within whitespace: At end of lines:
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     1
(*  Title:      HOL/Hilbert_Choice.thy
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
     2
    Author:     Lawrence C Paulson, Tobias Nipkow
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     3
    Copyright   2001  University of Cambridge
12023
wenzelm
parents: 11506
diff changeset
     4
*)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     5
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
     6
header {* Hilbert's Epsilon-Operator and the Axiom of Choice *}
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     7
15131
c69542757a4d New theory header syntax.
nipkow
parents: 14872
diff changeset
     8
theory Hilbert_Choice
29655
ac31940cfb69 Plain, Main form meeting points in import hierarchy
haftmann
parents: 27760
diff changeset
     9
imports Nat Wellfounded Plain
31723
f5cafe803b55 discontinued ancient tradition to suffix certain ML module names with "_package"
haftmann
parents: 31454
diff changeset
    10
uses ("Tools/meson.ML") ("Tools/choice_specification.ML")
15131
c69542757a4d New theory header syntax.
nipkow
parents: 14872
diff changeset
    11
begin
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
    12
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
    13
subsection {* Hilbert's epsilon *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
    14
31454
2c0959ab073f dropped legacy ML bindings; tuned
haftmann
parents: 31380
diff changeset
    15
axiomatization Eps :: "('a => bool) => 'a" where
22690
0b08f218f260 replaced axioms/finalconsts by proper axiomatization;
wenzelm
parents: 21999
diff changeset
    16
  someI: "P x ==> P (Eps P)"
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    17
14872
3f2144aebd76 improved symbolic syntax of Eps: \<some> for mode "epsilon";
wenzelm
parents: 14760
diff changeset
    18
syntax (epsilon)
3f2144aebd76 improved symbolic syntax of Eps: \<some> for mode "epsilon";
wenzelm
parents: 14760
diff changeset
    19
  "_Eps"        :: "[pttrn, bool] => 'a"    ("(3\<some>_./ _)" [0, 10] 10)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    20
syntax (HOL)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
    21
  "_Eps"        :: "[pttrn, bool] => 'a"    ("(3@ _./ _)" [0, 10] 10)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    22
syntax
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
    23
  "_Eps"        :: "[pttrn, bool] => 'a"    ("(3SOME _./ _)" [0, 10] 10)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    24
translations
22690
0b08f218f260 replaced axioms/finalconsts by proper axiomatization;
wenzelm
parents: 21999
diff changeset
    25
  "SOME x. P" == "CONST Eps (%x. P)"
13763
f94b569cd610 added print translations tha avoid eta contraction for important binders.
nipkow
parents: 13585
diff changeset
    26
f94b569cd610 added print translations tha avoid eta contraction for important binders.
nipkow
parents: 13585
diff changeset
    27
print_translation {*
35115
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
    28
  [(@{const_syntax Eps}, fn [Abs abs] =>
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
    29
      let val (x, t) = atomic_abs_tr' abs
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
    30
      in Syntax.const @{syntax_const "_Eps"} $ x $ t end)]
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
    31
*} -- {* to avoid eta-contraction of body *}
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    32
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
    33
definition inv_into :: "'a set => ('a => 'b) => ('b => 'a)" where
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
    34
"inv_into A f == %x. SOME y. y : A & f y = x"
11454
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
    35
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
    36
abbreviation inv :: "('a => 'b) => ('b => 'a)" where
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
    37
"inv == inv_into UNIV"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    38
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    39
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    40
subsection {*Hilbert's Epsilon-operator*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    41
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    42
text{*Easier to apply than @{text someI} if the witness comes from an
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    43
existential formula*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    44
lemma someI_ex [elim?]: "\<exists>x. P x ==> P (SOME x. P x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    45
apply (erule exE)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    46
apply (erule someI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    47
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    48
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    49
text{*Easier to apply than @{text someI} because the conclusion has only one
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    50
occurrence of @{term P}.*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    51
lemma someI2: "[| P a;  !!x. P x ==> Q x |] ==> Q (SOME x. P x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    52
by (blast intro: someI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    53
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    54
text{*Easier to apply than @{text someI2} if the witness comes from an
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    55
existential formula*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    56
lemma someI2_ex: "[| \<exists>a. P a; !!x. P x ==> Q x |] ==> Q (SOME x. P x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    57
by (blast intro: someI2)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    58
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    59
lemma some_equality [intro]:
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    60
     "[| P a;  !!x. P x ==> x=a |] ==> (SOME x. P x) = a"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    61
by (blast intro: someI2)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    62
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    63
lemma some1_equality: "[| EX!x. P x; P a |] ==> (SOME x. P x) = a"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    64
by (blast intro: some_equality)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    65
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    66
lemma some_eq_ex: "P (SOME x. P x) =  (\<exists>x. P x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    67
by (blast intro: someI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    68
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    69
lemma some_eq_trivial [simp]: "(SOME y. y=x) = x"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    70
apply (rule some_equality)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    71
apply (rule refl, assumption)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    72
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    73
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    74
lemma some_sym_eq_trivial [simp]: "(SOME y. x=y) = x"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    75
apply (rule some_equality)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    76
apply (rule refl)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    77
apply (erule sym)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    78
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    79
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    80
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    81
subsection{*Axiom of Choice, Proved Using the Description Operator*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    82
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    83
text{*Used in @{text "Tools/meson.ML"}*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    84
lemma choice: "\<forall>x. \<exists>y. Q x y ==> \<exists>f. \<forall>x. Q x (f x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    85
by (fast elim: someI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    86
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    87
lemma bchoice: "\<forall>x\<in>S. \<exists>y. Q x y ==> \<exists>f. \<forall>x\<in>S. Q x (f x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    88
by (fast elim: someI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    89
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    90
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    91
subsection {*Function Inverse*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
    92
33014
85d7a096e63f added inv_def for compatibility as a lemma
nipkow
parents: 32988
diff changeset
    93
lemma inv_def: "inv f = (%y. SOME x. f x = y)"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
    94
by(simp add: inv_into_def)
33014
85d7a096e63f added inv_def for compatibility as a lemma
nipkow
parents: 32988
diff changeset
    95
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
    96
lemma inv_into_into: "x : f ` A ==> inv_into A f x : A"
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
    97
apply (simp add: inv_into_def)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
    98
apply (fast intro: someI2)
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
    99
done
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   100
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   101
lemma inv_id [simp]: "inv id = id"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   102
by (simp add: inv_into_def id_def)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   103
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   104
lemma inv_into_f_f [simp]:
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   105
  "[| inj_on f A;  x : A |] ==> inv_into A f (f x) = x"
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   106
apply (simp add: inv_into_def inj_on_def)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   107
apply (blast intro: someI2)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   108
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   109
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   110
lemma inv_f_f: "inj f ==> inv f (f x) = x"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   111
by (simp add: inv_into_f_f)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   112
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   113
lemma f_inv_into_f: "y : f`A  ==> f (inv_into A f y) = y"
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   114
apply (simp add: inv_into_def)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   115
apply (fast intro: someI2)
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   116
done
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   117
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   118
lemma inv_into_f_eq: "[| inj_on f A; x : A; f x = y |] ==> inv_into A f y = x"
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   119
apply (erule subst)
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   120
apply (fast intro: inv_into_f_f)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   121
done
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   122
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   123
lemma inv_f_eq: "[| inj f; f x = y |] ==> inv f y = x"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   124
by (simp add:inv_into_f_eq)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   125
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   126
lemma inj_imp_inv_eq: "[| inj f; ALL x. f(g x) = x |] ==> inv f = g"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   127
by (blast intro: ext inv_into_f_eq)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   128
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   129
text{*But is it useful?*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   130
lemma inj_transfer:
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   131
  assumes injf: "inj f" and minor: "!!y. y \<in> range(f) ==> P(inv f y)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   132
  shows "P x"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   133
proof -
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   134
  have "f x \<in> range f" by auto
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   135
  hence "P(inv f (f x))" by (rule minor)
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   136
  thus "P x" by (simp add: inv_into_f_f [OF injf])
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   137
qed
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   138
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   139
lemma inj_iff: "(inj f) = (inv f o f = id)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   140
apply (simp add: o_def expand_fun_eq)
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   141
apply (blast intro: inj_on_inverseI inv_into_f_f)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   142
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   143
23433
c2c10abd2a1e added lemmas
nipkow
parents: 22690
diff changeset
   144
lemma inv_o_cancel[simp]: "inj f ==> inv f o f = id"
c2c10abd2a1e added lemmas
nipkow
parents: 22690
diff changeset
   145
by (simp add: inj_iff)
c2c10abd2a1e added lemmas
nipkow
parents: 22690
diff changeset
   146
c2c10abd2a1e added lemmas
nipkow
parents: 22690
diff changeset
   147
lemma o_inv_o_cancel[simp]: "inj f ==> g o inv f o f = g"
c2c10abd2a1e added lemmas
nipkow
parents: 22690
diff changeset
   148
by (simp add: o_assoc[symmetric])
c2c10abd2a1e added lemmas
nipkow
parents: 22690
diff changeset
   149
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   150
lemma inv_into_image_cancel[simp]:
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   151
  "inj_on f A ==> S <= A ==> inv_into A f ` f ` S = S"
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   152
by(fastsimp simp: image_def)
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   153
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   154
lemma inj_imp_surj_inv: "inj f ==> surj (inv f)"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   155
by (blast intro: surjI inv_into_f_f)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   156
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   157
lemma surj_f_inv_f: "surj f ==> f(inv f y) = y"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   158
by (simp add: f_inv_into_f surj_range)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   159
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   160
lemma inv_into_injective:
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   161
  assumes eq: "inv_into A f x = inv_into A f y"
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   162
      and x: "x: f`A"
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   163
      and y: "y: f`A"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   164
  shows "x=y"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   165
proof -
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   166
  have "f (inv_into A f x) = f (inv_into A f y)" using eq by simp
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   167
  thus ?thesis by (simp add: f_inv_into_f x y)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   168
qed
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   169
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   170
lemma inj_on_inv_into: "B <= f`A ==> inj_on (inv_into A f) B"
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   171
by (blast intro: inj_onI dest: inv_into_injective injD)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   172
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   173
lemma bij_betw_inv_into: "bij_betw f A B ==> bij_betw (inv_into A f) B A"
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   174
by (auto simp add: bij_betw_def inj_on_inv_into)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   175
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   176
lemma surj_imp_inj_inv: "surj f ==> inj (inv f)"
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   177
by (simp add: inj_on_inv_into surj_range)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   178
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   179
lemma surj_iff: "(surj f) = (f o inv f = id)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   180
apply (simp add: o_def expand_fun_eq)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   181
apply (blast intro: surjI surj_f_inv_f)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   182
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   183
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   184
lemma surj_imp_inv_eq: "[| surj f; \<forall>x. g(f x) = x |] ==> inv f = g"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   185
apply (rule ext)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   186
apply (drule_tac x = "inv f x" in spec)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   187
apply (simp add: surj_f_inv_f)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   188
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   189
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   190
lemma bij_imp_bij_inv: "bij f ==> bij (inv f)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   191
by (simp add: bij_def inj_imp_surj_inv surj_imp_inj_inv)
12372
cd3a09c7dac9 tuned declarations;
wenzelm
parents: 12298
diff changeset
   192
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   193
lemma inv_equality: "[| !!x. g (f x) = x;  !!y. f (g y) = y |] ==> inv f = g"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   194
apply (rule ext)
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   195
apply (auto simp add: inv_into_def)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   196
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   197
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   198
lemma inv_inv_eq: "bij f ==> inv (inv f) = f"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   199
apply (rule inv_equality)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   200
apply (auto simp add: bij_def surj_f_inv_f)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   201
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   202
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   203
(** bij(inv f) implies little about f.  Consider f::bool=>bool such that
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   204
    f(True)=f(False)=True.  Then it's consistent with axiom someI that
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   205
    inv f could be any function at all, including the identity function.
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   206
    If inv f=id then inv f is a bijection, but inj f, surj(f) and
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   207
    inv(inv f)=f all fail.
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   208
**)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   209
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   210
lemma inv_into_comp:
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   211
  "[| inj_on f (g ` A); inj_on g A; x : f ` g ` A |] ==>
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   212
  inv_into A (f o g) x = (inv_into A g o inv_into (g ` A) f) x"
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   213
apply (rule inv_into_f_eq)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   214
  apply (fast intro: comp_inj_on)
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   215
 apply (simp add: inv_into_into)
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   216
apply (simp add: f_inv_into_f inv_into_into)
32988
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   217
done
d1d4d7a08a66 Inv -> inv_onto, inv abbr. inv_onto UNIV.
nipkow
parents: 31723
diff changeset
   218
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   219
lemma o_inv_distrib: "[| bij f; bij g |] ==> inv (f o g) = inv g o inv f"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   220
apply (rule inv_equality)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   221
apply (auto simp add: bij_def surj_f_inv_f)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   222
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   223
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   224
lemma image_surj_f_inv_f: "surj f ==> f ` (inv f ` A) = A"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   225
by (simp add: image_eq_UN surj_f_inv_f)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   226
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   227
lemma image_inv_f_f: "inj f ==> (inv f) ` (f ` A) = A"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   228
by (simp add: image_eq_UN)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   229
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   230
lemma inv_image_comp: "inj f ==> inv f ` (f`X) = X"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   231
by (auto simp add: image_def)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   232
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   233
lemma bij_image_Collect_eq: "bij f ==> f ` Collect P = {y. P (inv f y)}"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   234
apply auto
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   235
apply (force simp add: bij_is_inj)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   236
apply (blast intro: bij_is_surj [THEN surj_f_inv_f, symmetric])
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   237
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   238
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   239
lemma bij_vimage_eq_inv_image: "bij f ==> f -` A = inv f ` A" 
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   240
apply (auto simp add: bij_is_surj [THEN surj_f_inv_f])
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   241
apply (blast intro: bij_is_inj [THEN inv_into_f_f, symmetric])
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   242
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   243
31380
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   244
lemma finite_fun_UNIVD1:
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   245
  assumes fin: "finite (UNIV :: ('a \<Rightarrow> 'b) set)"
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   246
  and card: "card (UNIV :: 'b set) \<noteq> Suc 0"
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   247
  shows "finite (UNIV :: 'a set)"
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   248
proof -
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   249
  from fin have finb: "finite (UNIV :: 'b set)" by (rule finite_fun_UNIVD2)
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   250
  with card have "card (UNIV :: 'b set) \<ge> Suc (Suc 0)"
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   251
    by (cases "card (UNIV :: 'b set)") (auto simp add: card_eq_0_iff)
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   252
  then obtain n where "card (UNIV :: 'b set) = Suc (Suc n)" "n = card (UNIV :: 'b set) - Suc (Suc 0)" by auto
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   253
  then obtain b1 b2 where b1b2: "(b1 :: 'b) \<noteq> (b2 :: 'b)" by (auto simp add: card_Suc_eq)
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   254
  from fin have "finite (range (\<lambda>f :: 'a \<Rightarrow> 'b. inv f b1))" by (rule finite_imageI)
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   255
  moreover have "UNIV = range (\<lambda>f :: 'a \<Rightarrow> 'b. inv f b1)"
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   256
  proof (rule UNIV_eq_I)
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   257
    fix x :: 'a
33057
764547b68538 inv_onto -> inv_into
nipkow
parents: 33014
diff changeset
   258
    from b1b2 have "x = inv (\<lambda>y. if y = x then b1 else b2) b1" by (simp add: inv_into_def)
31380
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   259
    thus "x \<in> range (\<lambda>f\<Colon>'a \<Rightarrow> 'b. inv f b1)" by blast
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   260
  qed
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   261
  ultimately show "finite (UNIV :: 'a set)" by simp
f25536c0bb80 added/moved lemmas by Andreas Lochbihler
haftmann
parents: 29655
diff changeset
   262
qed
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   263
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   264
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   265
subsection {*Other Consequences of Hilbert's Epsilon*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   266
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   267
text {*Hilbert's Epsilon and the @{term split} Operator*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   268
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   269
text{*Looping simprule*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   270
lemma split_paired_Eps: "(SOME x. P x) = (SOME (a,b). P(a,b))"
26347
105f55201077 tuned proofs
haftmann
parents: 26105
diff changeset
   271
  by simp
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   272
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   273
lemma Eps_split: "Eps (split P) = (SOME xy. P (fst xy) (snd xy))"
26347
105f55201077 tuned proofs
haftmann
parents: 26105
diff changeset
   274
  by (simp add: split_def)
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   275
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   276
lemma Eps_split_eq [simp]: "(@(x',y'). x = x' & y = y') = (x,y)"
26347
105f55201077 tuned proofs
haftmann
parents: 26105
diff changeset
   277
  by blast
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   278
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   279
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   280
text{*A relation is wellfounded iff it has no infinite descending chain*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   281
lemma wf_iff_no_infinite_down_chain:
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   282
  "wf r = (~(\<exists>f. \<forall>i. (f(Suc i),f i) \<in> r))"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   283
apply (simp only: wf_eq_minimal)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   284
apply (rule iffI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   285
 apply (rule notI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   286
 apply (erule exE)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   287
 apply (erule_tac x = "{w. \<exists>i. w=f i}" in allE, blast)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   288
apply (erule contrapos_np, simp, clarify)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   289
apply (subgoal_tac "\<forall>n. nat_rec x (%i y. @z. z:Q & (z,y) :r) n \<in> Q")
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   290
 apply (rule_tac x = "nat_rec x (%i y. @z. z:Q & (z,y) :r)" in exI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   291
 apply (rule allI, simp)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   292
 apply (rule someI2_ex, blast, blast)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   293
apply (rule allI)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   294
apply (induct_tac "n", simp_all)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   295
apply (rule someI2_ex, blast+)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   296
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   297
27760
3aa86edac080 added lemma
nipkow
parents: 26748
diff changeset
   298
lemma wf_no_infinite_down_chainE:
3aa86edac080 added lemma
nipkow
parents: 26748
diff changeset
   299
  assumes "wf r" obtains k where "(f (Suc k), f k) \<notin> r"
3aa86edac080 added lemma
nipkow
parents: 26748
diff changeset
   300
using `wf r` wf_iff_no_infinite_down_chain[of r] by blast
3aa86edac080 added lemma
nipkow
parents: 26748
diff changeset
   301
3aa86edac080 added lemma
nipkow
parents: 26748
diff changeset
   302
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   303
text{*A dynamically-scoped fact for TFL *}
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   304
lemma tfl_some: "\<forall>P x. P x --> P (Eps P)"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   305
  by (blast intro: someI)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   306
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   307
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   308
subsection {* Least value operator *}
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   309
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   310
constdefs
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   311
  LeastM :: "['a => 'b::ord, 'a => bool] => 'a"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   312
  "LeastM m P == SOME x. P x & (\<forall>y. P y --> m x <= m y)"
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   313
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   314
syntax
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   315
  "_LeastM" :: "[pttrn, 'a => 'b::ord, bool] => 'a"    ("LEAST _ WRT _. _" [0, 4, 10] 10)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   316
translations
35115
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
   317
  "LEAST x WRT m. P" == "CONST LeastM m (%x. P)"
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   318
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   319
lemma LeastMI2:
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   320
  "P x ==> (!!y. P y ==> m x <= m y)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   321
    ==> (!!x. P x ==> \<forall>y. P y --> m x \<le> m y ==> Q x)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   322
    ==> Q (LeastM m P)"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   323
  apply (simp add: LeastM_def)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   324
  apply (rule someI2_ex, blast, blast)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   325
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   326
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   327
lemma LeastM_equality:
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   328
  "P k ==> (!!x. P x ==> m k <= m x)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   329
    ==> m (LEAST x WRT m. P x) = (m k::'a::order)"
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   330
  apply (rule LeastMI2, assumption, blast)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   331
  apply (blast intro!: order_antisym)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   332
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   333
11454
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   334
lemma wf_linord_ex_has_least:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   335
  "wf r ==> \<forall>x y. ((x,y):r^+) = ((y,x)~:r^*) ==> P k
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   336
    ==> \<exists>x. P x & (!y. P y --> (m x,m y):r^*)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   337
  apply (drule wf_trancl [THEN wf_eq_minimal [THEN iffD1]])
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   338
  apply (drule_tac x = "m`Collect P" in spec, force)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   339
  done
11454
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   340
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   341
lemma ex_has_least_nat:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   342
    "P k ==> \<exists>x. P x & (\<forall>y. P y --> m x <= (m y::nat))"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   343
  apply (simp only: pred_nat_trancl_eq_le [symmetric])
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   344
  apply (rule wf_pred_nat [THEN wf_linord_ex_has_least])
16796
140f1e0ea846 generlization of some "nat" theorems
paulson
parents: 16563
diff changeset
   345
   apply (simp add: less_eq linorder_not_le pred_nat_trancl_eq_le, assumption)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   346
  done
11454
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   347
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   348
lemma LeastM_nat_lemma:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   349
    "P k ==> P (LeastM m P) & (\<forall>y. P y --> m (LeastM m P) <= (m y::nat))"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   350
  apply (simp add: LeastM_def)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   351
  apply (rule someI_ex)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   352
  apply (erule ex_has_least_nat)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   353
  done
11454
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   354
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   355
lemmas LeastM_natI = LeastM_nat_lemma [THEN conjunct1, standard]
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   356
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   357
lemma LeastM_nat_le: "P x ==> m (LeastM m P) <= (m x::nat)"
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   358
by (rule LeastM_nat_lemma [THEN conjunct2, THEN spec, THEN mp], assumption, assumption)
11454
7514e5e21cb8 Hilbert restructuring: Wellfounded_Relations no longer needs Hilbert_Choice
paulson
parents: 11451
diff changeset
   359
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   360
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   361
subsection {* Greatest value operator *}
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   362
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   363
constdefs
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   364
  GreatestM :: "['a => 'b::ord, 'a => bool] => 'a"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   365
  "GreatestM m P == SOME x. P x & (\<forall>y. P y --> m y <= m x)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   366
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   367
  Greatest :: "('a::ord => bool) => 'a"    (binder "GREATEST " 10)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   368
  "Greatest == GreatestM (%x. x)"
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   369
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   370
syntax
35115
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
   371
  "_GreatestM" :: "[pttrn, 'a => 'b::ord, bool] => 'a"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   372
      ("GREATEST _ WRT _. _" [0, 4, 10] 10)
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   373
translations
35115
446c5063e4fd modernized translations;
wenzelm
parents: 33057
diff changeset
   374
  "GREATEST x WRT m. P" == "CONST GreatestM m (%x. P)"
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   375
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   376
lemma GreatestMI2:
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   377
  "P x ==> (!!y. P y ==> m y <= m x)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   378
    ==> (!!x. P x ==> \<forall>y. P y --> m y \<le> m x ==> Q x)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   379
    ==> Q (GreatestM m P)"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   380
  apply (simp add: GreatestM_def)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   381
  apply (rule someI2_ex, blast, blast)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   382
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   383
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   384
lemma GreatestM_equality:
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   385
 "P k ==> (!!x. P x ==> m x <= m k)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   386
    ==> m (GREATEST x WRT m. P x) = (m k::'a::order)"
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   387
  apply (rule_tac m = m in GreatestMI2, assumption, blast)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   388
  apply (blast intro!: order_antisym)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   389
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   390
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   391
lemma Greatest_equality:
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   392
  "P (k::'a::order) ==> (!!x. P x ==> x <= k) ==> (GREATEST x. P x) = k"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   393
  apply (simp add: Greatest_def)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   394
  apply (erule GreatestM_equality, blast)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   395
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   396
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   397
lemma ex_has_greatest_nat_lemma:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   398
  "P k ==> \<forall>x. P x --> (\<exists>y. P y & ~ ((m y::nat) <= m x))
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   399
    ==> \<exists>y. P y & ~ (m y < m k + n)"
15251
bb6f072c8d10 converted some induct_tac to induct
paulson
parents: 15140
diff changeset
   400
  apply (induct n, force)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   401
  apply (force simp add: le_Suc_eq)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   402
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   403
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   404
lemma ex_has_greatest_nat:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   405
  "P k ==> \<forall>y. P y --> m y < b
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   406
    ==> \<exists>x. P x & (\<forall>y. P y --> (m y::nat) <= m x)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   407
  apply (rule ccontr)
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   408
  apply (cut_tac P = P and n = "b - m k" in ex_has_greatest_nat_lemma)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   409
    apply (subgoal_tac [3] "m k <= b", auto)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   410
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   411
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   412
lemma GreatestM_nat_lemma:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   413
  "P k ==> \<forall>y. P y --> m y < b
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   414
    ==> P (GreatestM m P) & (\<forall>y. P y --> (m y::nat) <= m (GreatestM m P))"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   415
  apply (simp add: GreatestM_def)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   416
  apply (rule someI_ex)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   417
  apply (erule ex_has_greatest_nat, assumption)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   418
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   419
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   420
lemmas GreatestM_natI = GreatestM_nat_lemma [THEN conjunct1, standard]
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   421
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   422
lemma GreatestM_nat_le:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   423
  "P x ==> \<forall>y. P y --> m y < b
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   424
    ==> (m x::nat) <= m (GreatestM m P)"
21020
9af9ceb16d58 Adapted to changes in FixedPoint theory.
berghofe
parents: 18389
diff changeset
   425
  apply (blast dest: GreatestM_nat_lemma [THEN conjunct2, THEN spec, of P])
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   426
  done
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   427
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   428
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   429
text {* \medskip Specialization to @{text GREATEST}. *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   430
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   431
lemma GreatestI: "P (k::nat) ==> \<forall>y. P y --> y < b ==> P (GREATEST x. P x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   432
  apply (simp add: Greatest_def)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   433
  apply (rule GreatestM_natI, auto)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   434
  done
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   435
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   436
lemma Greatest_le:
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   437
    "P x ==> \<forall>y. P y --> y < b ==> (x::nat) <= (GREATEST x. P x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   438
  apply (simp add: Greatest_def)
14208
144f45277d5a misc tidying
paulson
parents: 14115
diff changeset
   439
  apply (rule GreatestM_nat_le, auto)
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   440
  done
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   441
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   442
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   443
subsection {* The Meson proof procedure *}
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   444
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   445
subsubsection {* Negation Normal Form *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   446
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   447
text {* de Morgan laws *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   448
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   449
lemma meson_not_conjD: "~(P&Q) ==> ~P | ~Q"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   450
  and meson_not_disjD: "~(P|Q) ==> ~P & ~Q"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   451
  and meson_not_notD: "~~P ==> P"
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   452
  and meson_not_allD: "!!P. ~(\<forall>x. P(x)) ==> \<exists>x. ~P(x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   453
  and meson_not_exD: "!!P. ~(\<exists>x. P(x)) ==> \<forall>x. ~P(x)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   454
  by fast+
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   455
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   456
text {* Removal of @{text "-->"} and @{text "<->"} (positive and
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   457
negative occurrences) *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   458
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   459
lemma meson_imp_to_disjD: "P-->Q ==> ~P | Q"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   460
  and meson_not_impD: "~(P-->Q) ==> P & ~Q"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   461
  and meson_iff_to_disjD: "P=Q ==> (~P | Q) & (~Q | P)"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   462
  and meson_not_iffD: "~(P=Q) ==> (P | Q) & (~P | ~Q)"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   463
    -- {* Much more efficient than @{prop "(P & ~Q) | (Q & ~P)"} for computing CNF *}
18389
8352b1d3b639 removal of functional reflexivity axioms
paulson
parents: 17893
diff changeset
   464
  and meson_not_refl_disj_D: "x ~= x | P ==> P"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   465
  by fast+
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   466
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   467
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   468
subsubsection {* Pulling out the existential quantifiers *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   469
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   470
text {* Conjunction *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   471
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   472
lemma meson_conj_exD1: "!!P Q. (\<exists>x. P(x)) & Q ==> \<exists>x. P(x) & Q"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   473
  and meson_conj_exD2: "!!P Q. P & (\<exists>x. Q(x)) ==> \<exists>x. P & Q(x)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   474
  by fast+
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   475
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   476
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   477
text {* Disjunction *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   478
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   479
lemma meson_disj_exD: "!!P Q. (\<exists>x. P(x)) | (\<exists>x. Q(x)) ==> \<exists>x. P(x) | Q(x)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   480
  -- {* DO NOT USE with forall-Skolemization: makes fewer schematic variables!! *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   481
  -- {* With ex-Skolemization, makes fewer Skolem constants *}
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   482
  and meson_disj_exD1: "!!P Q. (\<exists>x. P(x)) | Q ==> \<exists>x. P(x) | Q"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   483
  and meson_disj_exD2: "!!P Q. P | (\<exists>x. Q(x)) ==> \<exists>x. P | Q(x)"
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   484
  by fast+
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   485
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   486
12298
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   487
subsubsection {* Generating clauses for the Meson Proof Procedure *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   488
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   489
text {* Disjunctions *}
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   490
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   491
lemma meson_disj_assoc: "(P|Q)|R ==> P|(Q|R)"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   492
  and meson_disj_comm: "P|Q ==> Q|P"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   493
  and meson_disj_FalseD1: "False|P ==> P"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   494
  and meson_disj_FalseD2: "P|False ==> P"
wenzelm
parents: 12023
diff changeset
   495
  by fast+
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   496
14760
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   497
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   498
subsection{*Lemmas for Meson, the Model Elimination Procedure*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   499
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   500
text{* Generation of contrapositives *}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   501
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   502
text{*Inserts negated disjunct after removing the negation; P is a literal.
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   503
  Model elimination requires assuming the negation of every attempted subgoal,
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   504
  hence the negated disjuncts.*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   505
lemma make_neg_rule: "~P|Q ==> ((~P==>P) ==> Q)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   506
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   507
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   508
text{*Version for Plaisted's "Postive refinement" of the Meson procedure*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   509
lemma make_refined_neg_rule: "~P|Q ==> (P ==> Q)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   510
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   511
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   512
text{*@{term P} should be a literal*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   513
lemma make_pos_rule: "P|Q ==> ((P==>~P) ==> Q)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   514
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   515
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   516
text{*Versions of @{text make_neg_rule} and @{text make_pos_rule} that don't
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   517
insert new assumptions, for ordinary resolution.*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   518
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   519
lemmas make_neg_rule' = make_refined_neg_rule
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   520
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   521
lemma make_pos_rule': "[|P|Q; ~P|] ==> Q"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   522
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   523
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   524
text{* Generation of a goal clause -- put away the final literal *}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   525
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   526
lemma make_neg_goal: "~P ==> ((~P==>P) ==> False)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   527
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   528
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   529
lemma make_pos_goal: "P ==> ((P==>~P) ==> False)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   530
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   531
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   532
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   533
subsubsection{* Lemmas for Forward Proof*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   534
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   535
text{*There is a similarity to congruence rules*}
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   536
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   537
(*NOTE: could handle conjunctions (faster?) by
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   538
    nf(th RS conjunct2) RS (nf(th RS conjunct1) RS conjI) *)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   539
lemma conj_forward: "[| P'&Q';  P' ==> P;  Q' ==> Q |] ==> P&Q"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   540
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   541
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   542
lemma disj_forward: "[| P'|Q';  P' ==> P;  Q' ==> Q |] ==> P|Q"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   543
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   544
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   545
(*Version of @{text disj_forward} for removal of duplicate literals*)
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   546
lemma disj_forward2:
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   547
    "[| P'|Q';  P' ==> P;  [| Q'; P==>False |] ==> Q |] ==> P|Q"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   548
apply blast 
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   549
done
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   550
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   551
lemma all_forward: "[| \<forall>x. P'(x);  !!x. P'(x) ==> P(x) |] ==> \<forall>x. P(x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   552
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   553
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   554
lemma ex_forward: "[| \<exists>x. P'(x);  !!x. P'(x) ==> P(x) |] ==> \<exists>x. P(x)"
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   555
by blast
a08e916f4946 conversion of Hilbert_Choice to Isar script
paulson
parents: 14399
diff changeset
   556
17420
bdcffa8d8665 comment
paulson
parents: 16796
diff changeset
   557
21999
0cf192e489e2 improvements to proof reconstruction. Some files loaded in a different order
paulson
parents: 21243
diff changeset
   558
subsection {* Meson package *}
17893
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   559
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   560
use "Tools/meson.ML"
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   561
26562
9d25ef112cf6 * Metis: the maximum number of clauses that can be produced from a theorem is now given by the attribute max_clauses. Theorems that exceed this number are ignored, with a warning printed.
paulson
parents: 26347
diff changeset
   562
setup Meson.setup
9d25ef112cf6 * Metis: the maximum number of clauses that can be produced from a theorem is now given by the attribute max_clauses. Theorems that exceed this number are ignored, with a warning printed.
paulson
parents: 26347
diff changeset
   563
17893
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   564
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   565
subsection {* Specification package -- Hilbertized version *}
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   566
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   567
lemma exE_some: "[| Ex P ; c == Eps P |] ==> P c"
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   568
  by (simp only: someI_ex)
aef5a6d11c2a added lemma exE_some (from specification_package.ML);
wenzelm
parents: 17702
diff changeset
   569
31723
f5cafe803b55 discontinued ancient tradition to suffix certain ML module names with "_package"
haftmann
parents: 31454
diff changeset
   570
use "Tools/choice_specification.ML"
14115
65ec3f73d00b Added package for definition by specification.
skalberg
parents: 13764
diff changeset
   571
31454
2c0959ab073f dropped legacy ML bindings; tuned
haftmann
parents: 31380
diff changeset
   572
11451
8abfb4f7bd02 partial restructuring to reduce dependence on Axiom of Choice
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   573
end