src/ZF/Order.thy
 author paulson Tue Mar 06 16:06:52 2012 +0000 (2012-03-06) changeset 46821 ff6b0c1087f2 parent 46820 c656222c4dc1 child 46953 2b6e55924af3 permissions -rw-r--r--
Using mathematical notation for <-> and cardinal arithmetic
```     1 (*  Title:      ZF/Order.thy
```
```     2     Author:     Lawrence C Paulson, Cambridge University Computer Laboratory
```
```     3     Copyright   1994  University of Cambridge
```
```     4
```
```     5 Results from the book "Set Theory: an Introduction to Independence Proofs"
```
```     6         by Kenneth Kunen.  Chapter 1, section 6.
```
```     7 Additional definitions and lemmas for reflexive orders.
```
```     8 *)
```
```     9
```
```    10 header{*Partial and Total Orderings: Basic Definitions and Properties*}
```
```    11
```
```    12 theory Order imports WF Perm begin
```
```    13
```
```    14 text {* We adopt the following convention: @{text ord} is used for
```
```    15   strict orders and @{text order} is used for their reflexive
```
```    16   counterparts. *}
```
```    17
```
```    18 definition
```
```    19   part_ord :: "[i,i]=>o"                (*Strict partial ordering*)  where
```
```    20    "part_ord(A,r) == irrefl(A,r) & trans[A](r)"
```
```    21
```
```    22 definition
```
```    23   linear   :: "[i,i]=>o"                (*Strict total ordering*)  where
```
```    24    "linear(A,r) == (\<forall>x\<in>A. \<forall>y\<in>A. <x,y>:r | x=y | <y,x>:r)"
```
```    25
```
```    26 definition
```
```    27   tot_ord  :: "[i,i]=>o"                (*Strict total ordering*)  where
```
```    28    "tot_ord(A,r) == part_ord(A,r) & linear(A,r)"
```
```    29
```
```    30 definition
```
```    31   "preorder_on(A, r) \<equiv> refl(A, r) \<and> trans[A](r)"
```
```    32
```
```    33 definition                              (*Partial ordering*)
```
```    34   "partial_order_on(A, r) \<equiv> preorder_on(A, r) \<and> antisym(r)"
```
```    35
```
```    36 abbreviation
```
```    37   "Preorder(r) \<equiv> preorder_on(field(r), r)"
```
```    38
```
```    39 abbreviation
```
```    40   "Partial_order(r) \<equiv> partial_order_on(field(r), r)"
```
```    41
```
```    42 definition
```
```    43   well_ord :: "[i,i]=>o"                (*Well-ordering*)  where
```
```    44    "well_ord(A,r) == tot_ord(A,r) & wf[A](r)"
```
```    45
```
```    46 definition
```
```    47   mono_map :: "[i,i,i,i]=>i"            (*Order-preserving maps*)  where
```
```    48    "mono_map(A,r,B,s) ==
```
```    49               {f: A->B. \<forall>x\<in>A. \<forall>y\<in>A. <x,y>:r \<longrightarrow> <f`x,f`y>:s}"
```
```    50
```
```    51 definition
```
```    52   ord_iso  :: "[i,i,i,i]=>i"            (*Order isomorphisms*)  where
```
```    53    "ord_iso(A,r,B,s) ==
```
```    54               {f: bij(A,B). \<forall>x\<in>A. \<forall>y\<in>A. <x,y>:r \<longleftrightarrow> <f`x,f`y>:s}"
```
```    55
```
```    56 definition
```
```    57   pred     :: "[i,i,i]=>i"              (*Set of predecessors*)  where
```
```    58    "pred(A,x,r) == {y:A. <y,x>:r}"
```
```    59
```
```    60 definition
```
```    61   ord_iso_map :: "[i,i,i,i]=>i"         (*Construction for linearity theorem*)  where
```
```    62    "ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s) ==
```
```    63      \<Union>x\<in>A. \<Union>y\<in>B. \<Union>f \<in> ord_iso(pred(A,x,r), r, pred(B,y,s), s). {<x,y>}"
```
```    64
```
```    65 definition
```
```    66   first :: "[i, i, i] => o"  where
```
```    67     "first(u, X, R) == u:X & (\<forall>v\<in>X. v\<noteq>u \<longrightarrow> <u,v> \<in> R)"
```
```    68
```
```    69
```
```    70 notation (xsymbols)
```
```    71   ord_iso  ("(\<langle>_, _\<rangle> \<cong>/ \<langle>_, _\<rangle>)" 51)
```
```    72
```
```    73
```
```    74 subsection{*Immediate Consequences of the Definitions*}
```
```    75
```
```    76 lemma part_ord_Imp_asym:
```
```    77     "part_ord(A,r) ==> asym(r \<inter> A*A)"
```
```    78 by (unfold part_ord_def irrefl_def trans_on_def asym_def, blast)
```
```    79
```
```    80 lemma linearE:
```
```    81     "[| linear(A,r);  x:A;  y:A;
```
```    82         <x,y>:r ==> P;  x=y ==> P;  <y,x>:r ==> P |]
```
```    83      ==> P"
```
```    84 by (simp add: linear_def, blast)
```
```    85
```
```    86
```
```    87 (** General properties of well_ord **)
```
```    88
```
```    89 lemma well_ordI:
```
```    90     "[| wf[A](r); linear(A,r) |] ==> well_ord(A,r)"
```
```    91 apply (simp add: irrefl_def part_ord_def tot_ord_def
```
```    92                  trans_on_def well_ord_def wf_on_not_refl)
```
```    93 apply (fast elim: linearE wf_on_asym wf_on_chain3)
```
```    94 done
```
```    95
```
```    96 lemma well_ord_is_wf:
```
```    97     "well_ord(A,r) ==> wf[A](r)"
```
```    98 by (unfold well_ord_def, safe)
```
```    99
```
```   100 lemma well_ord_is_trans_on:
```
```   101     "well_ord(A,r) ==> trans[A](r)"
```
```   102 by (unfold well_ord_def tot_ord_def part_ord_def, safe)
```
```   103
```
```   104 lemma well_ord_is_linear: "well_ord(A,r) ==> linear(A,r)"
```
```   105 by (unfold well_ord_def tot_ord_def, blast)
```
```   106
```
```   107
```
```   108 (** Derived rules for pred(A,x,r) **)
```
```   109
```
```   110 lemma pred_iff: "y \<in> pred(A,x,r) \<longleftrightarrow> <y,x>:r & y:A"
```
```   111 by (unfold pred_def, blast)
```
```   112
```
```   113 lemmas predI = conjI [THEN pred_iff [THEN iffD2]]
```
```   114
```
```   115 lemma predE: "[| y: pred(A,x,r);  [| y:A; <y,x>:r |] ==> P |] ==> P"
```
```   116 by (simp add: pred_def)
```
```   117
```
```   118 lemma pred_subset_under: "pred(A,x,r) \<subseteq> r -`` {x}"
```
```   119 by (simp add: pred_def, blast)
```
```   120
```
```   121 lemma pred_subset: "pred(A,x,r) \<subseteq> A"
```
```   122 by (simp add: pred_def, blast)
```
```   123
```
```   124 lemma pred_pred_eq:
```
```   125     "pred(pred(A,x,r), y, r) = pred(A,x,r) \<inter> pred(A,y,r)"
```
```   126 by (simp add: pred_def, blast)
```
```   127
```
```   128 lemma trans_pred_pred_eq:
```
```   129     "[| trans[A](r);  <y,x>:r;  x:A;  y:A |]
```
```   130      ==> pred(pred(A,x,r), y, r) = pred(A,y,r)"
```
```   131 by (unfold trans_on_def pred_def, blast)
```
```   132
```
```   133
```
```   134 subsection{*Restricting an Ordering's Domain*}
```
```   135
```
```   136 (** The ordering's properties hold over all subsets of its domain
```
```   137     [including initial segments of the form pred(A,x,r) **)
```
```   138
```
```   139 (*Note: a relation s such that s<=r need not be a partial ordering*)
```
```   140 lemma part_ord_subset:
```
```   141     "[| part_ord(A,r);  B<=A |] ==> part_ord(B,r)"
```
```   142 by (unfold part_ord_def irrefl_def trans_on_def, blast)
```
```   143
```
```   144 lemma linear_subset:
```
```   145     "[| linear(A,r);  B<=A |] ==> linear(B,r)"
```
```   146 by (unfold linear_def, blast)
```
```   147
```
```   148 lemma tot_ord_subset:
```
```   149     "[| tot_ord(A,r);  B<=A |] ==> tot_ord(B,r)"
```
```   150 apply (unfold tot_ord_def)
```
```   151 apply (fast elim!: part_ord_subset linear_subset)
```
```   152 done
```
```   153
```
```   154 lemma well_ord_subset:
```
```   155     "[| well_ord(A,r);  B<=A |] ==> well_ord(B,r)"
```
```   156 apply (unfold well_ord_def)
```
```   157 apply (fast elim!: tot_ord_subset wf_on_subset_A)
```
```   158 done
```
```   159
```
```   160
```
```   161 (** Relations restricted to a smaller domain, by Krzysztof Grabczewski **)
```
```   162
```
```   163 lemma irrefl_Int_iff: "irrefl(A,r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> irrefl(A,r)"
```
```   164 by (unfold irrefl_def, blast)
```
```   165
```
```   166 lemma trans_on_Int_iff: "trans[A](r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> trans[A](r)"
```
```   167 by (unfold trans_on_def, blast)
```
```   168
```
```   169 lemma part_ord_Int_iff: "part_ord(A,r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> part_ord(A,r)"
```
```   170 apply (unfold part_ord_def)
```
```   171 apply (simp add: irrefl_Int_iff trans_on_Int_iff)
```
```   172 done
```
```   173
```
```   174 lemma linear_Int_iff: "linear(A,r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> linear(A,r)"
```
```   175 by (unfold linear_def, blast)
```
```   176
```
```   177 lemma tot_ord_Int_iff: "tot_ord(A,r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> tot_ord(A,r)"
```
```   178 apply (unfold tot_ord_def)
```
```   179 apply (simp add: part_ord_Int_iff linear_Int_iff)
```
```   180 done
```
```   181
```
```   182 lemma wf_on_Int_iff: "wf[A](r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> wf[A](r)"
```
```   183 apply (unfold wf_on_def wf_def, fast) (*10 times faster than blast!*)
```
```   184 done
```
```   185
```
```   186 lemma well_ord_Int_iff: "well_ord(A,r \<inter> A*A) \<longleftrightarrow> well_ord(A,r)"
```
```   187 apply (unfold well_ord_def)
```
```   188 apply (simp add: tot_ord_Int_iff wf_on_Int_iff)
```
```   189 done
```
```   190
```
```   191
```
```   192 subsection{*Empty and Unit Domains*}
```
```   193
```
```   194 (*The empty relation is well-founded*)
```
```   195 lemma wf_on_any_0: "wf[A](0)"
```
```   196 by (simp add: wf_on_def wf_def, fast)
```
```   197
```
```   198 subsubsection{*Relations over the Empty Set*}
```
```   199
```
```   200 lemma irrefl_0: "irrefl(0,r)"
```
```   201 by (unfold irrefl_def, blast)
```
```   202
```
```   203 lemma trans_on_0: "trans[0](r)"
```
```   204 by (unfold trans_on_def, blast)
```
```   205
```
```   206 lemma part_ord_0: "part_ord(0,r)"
```
```   207 apply (unfold part_ord_def)
```
```   208 apply (simp add: irrefl_0 trans_on_0)
```
```   209 done
```
```   210
```
```   211 lemma linear_0: "linear(0,r)"
```
```   212 by (unfold linear_def, blast)
```
```   213
```
```   214 lemma tot_ord_0: "tot_ord(0,r)"
```
```   215 apply (unfold tot_ord_def)
```
```   216 apply (simp add: part_ord_0 linear_0)
```
```   217 done
```
```   218
```
```   219 lemma wf_on_0: "wf[0](r)"
```
```   220 by (unfold wf_on_def wf_def, blast)
```
```   221
```
```   222 lemma well_ord_0: "well_ord(0,r)"
```
```   223 apply (unfold well_ord_def)
```
```   224 apply (simp add: tot_ord_0 wf_on_0)
```
```   225 done
```
```   226
```
```   227
```
```   228 subsubsection{*The Empty Relation Well-Orders the Unit Set*}
```
```   229
```
```   230 text{*by Grabczewski*}
```
```   231
```
```   232 lemma tot_ord_unit: "tot_ord({a},0)"
```
```   233 by (simp add: irrefl_def trans_on_def part_ord_def linear_def tot_ord_def)
```
```   234
```
```   235 lemma well_ord_unit: "well_ord({a},0)"
```
```   236 apply (unfold well_ord_def)
```
```   237 apply (simp add: tot_ord_unit wf_on_any_0)
```
```   238 done
```
```   239
```
```   240
```
```   241 subsection{*Order-Isomorphisms*}
```
```   242
```
```   243 text{*Suppes calls them "similarities"*}
```
```   244
```
```   245 (** Order-preserving (monotone) maps **)
```
```   246
```
```   247 lemma mono_map_is_fun: "f: mono_map(A,r,B,s) ==> f: A->B"
```
```   248 by (simp add: mono_map_def)
```
```   249
```
```   250 lemma mono_map_is_inj:
```
```   251     "[| linear(A,r);  wf[B](s);  f: mono_map(A,r,B,s) |] ==> f: inj(A,B)"
```
```   252 apply (unfold mono_map_def inj_def, clarify)
```
```   253 apply (erule_tac x=w and y=x in linearE, assumption+)
```
```   254 apply (force intro: apply_type dest: wf_on_not_refl)+
```
```   255 done
```
```   256
```
```   257 lemma ord_isoI:
```
```   258     "[| f: bij(A, B);
```
```   259         !!x y. [| x:A; y:A |] ==> <x, y> \<in> r \<longleftrightarrow> <f`x, f`y> \<in> s |]
```
```   260      ==> f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s)"
```
```   261 by (simp add: ord_iso_def)
```
```   262
```
```   263 lemma ord_iso_is_mono_map:
```
```   264     "f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) ==> f: mono_map(A,r,B,s)"
```
```   265 apply (simp add: ord_iso_def mono_map_def)
```
```   266 apply (blast dest!: bij_is_fun)
```
```   267 done
```
```   268
```
```   269 lemma ord_iso_is_bij:
```
```   270     "f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) ==> f: bij(A,B)"
```
```   271 by (simp add: ord_iso_def)
```
```   272
```
```   273 (*Needed?  But ord_iso_converse is!*)
```
```   274 lemma ord_iso_apply:
```
```   275     "[| f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s);  <x,y>: r;  x:A;  y:A |] ==> <f`x, f`y> \<in> s"
```
```   276 by (simp add: ord_iso_def)
```
```   277
```
```   278 lemma ord_iso_converse:
```
```   279     "[| f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s);  <x,y>: s;  x:B;  y:B |]
```
```   280      ==> <converse(f) ` x, converse(f) ` y> \<in> r"
```
```   281 apply (simp add: ord_iso_def, clarify)
```
```   282 apply (erule bspec [THEN bspec, THEN iffD2])
```
```   283 apply (erule asm_rl bij_converse_bij [THEN bij_is_fun, THEN apply_type])+
```
```   284 apply (auto simp add: right_inverse_bij)
```
```   285 done
```
```   286
```
```   287
```
```   288 (** Symmetry and Transitivity Rules **)
```
```   289
```
```   290 (*Reflexivity of similarity*)
```
```   291 lemma ord_iso_refl: "id(A): ord_iso(A,r,A,r)"
```
```   292 by (rule id_bij [THEN ord_isoI], simp)
```
```   293
```
```   294 (*Symmetry of similarity*)
```
```   295 lemma ord_iso_sym: "f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) ==> converse(f): ord_iso(B,s,A,r)"
```
```   296 apply (simp add: ord_iso_def)
```
```   297 apply (auto simp add: right_inverse_bij bij_converse_bij
```
```   298                       bij_is_fun [THEN apply_funtype])
```
```   299 done
```
```   300
```
```   301 (*Transitivity of similarity*)
```
```   302 lemma mono_map_trans:
```
```   303     "[| g: mono_map(A,r,B,s);  f: mono_map(B,s,C,t) |]
```
```   304      ==> (f O g): mono_map(A,r,C,t)"
```
```   305 apply (unfold mono_map_def)
```
```   306 apply (auto simp add: comp_fun)
```
```   307 done
```
```   308
```
```   309 (*Transitivity of similarity: the order-isomorphism relation*)
```
```   310 lemma ord_iso_trans:
```
```   311     "[| g: ord_iso(A,r,B,s);  f: ord_iso(B,s,C,t) |]
```
```   312      ==> (f O g): ord_iso(A,r,C,t)"
```
```   313 apply (unfold ord_iso_def, clarify)
```
```   314 apply (frule bij_is_fun [of f])
```
```   315 apply (frule bij_is_fun [of g])
```
```   316 apply (auto simp add: comp_bij)
```
```   317 done
```
```   318
```
```   319 (** Two monotone maps can make an order-isomorphism **)
```
```   320
```
```   321 lemma mono_ord_isoI:
```
```   322     "[| f: mono_map(A,r,B,s);  g: mono_map(B,s,A,r);
```
```   323         f O g = id(B);  g O f = id(A) |] ==> f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s)"
```
```   324 apply (simp add: ord_iso_def mono_map_def, safe)
```
```   325 apply (intro fg_imp_bijective, auto)
```
```   326 apply (subgoal_tac "<g` (f`x), g` (f`y) > \<in> r")
```
```   327 apply (simp add: comp_eq_id_iff [THEN iffD1])
```
```   328 apply (blast intro: apply_funtype)
```
```   329 done
```
```   330
```
```   331 lemma well_ord_mono_ord_isoI:
```
```   332      "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s);
```
```   333          f: mono_map(A,r,B,s);  converse(f): mono_map(B,s,A,r) |]
```
```   334       ==> f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s)"
```
```   335 apply (intro mono_ord_isoI, auto)
```
```   336 apply (frule mono_map_is_fun [THEN fun_is_rel])
```
```   337 apply (erule converse_converse [THEN subst], rule left_comp_inverse)
```
```   338 apply (blast intro: left_comp_inverse mono_map_is_inj well_ord_is_linear
```
```   339                     well_ord_is_wf)+
```
```   340 done
```
```   341
```
```   342
```
```   343 (** Order-isomorphisms preserve the ordering's properties **)
```
```   344
```
```   345 lemma part_ord_ord_iso:
```
```   346     "[| part_ord(B,s);  f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) |] ==> part_ord(A,r)"
```
```   347 apply (simp add: part_ord_def irrefl_def trans_on_def ord_iso_def)
```
```   348 apply (fast intro: bij_is_fun [THEN apply_type])
```
```   349 done
```
```   350
```
```   351 lemma linear_ord_iso:
```
```   352     "[| linear(B,s);  f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) |] ==> linear(A,r)"
```
```   353 apply (simp add: linear_def ord_iso_def, safe)
```
```   354 apply (drule_tac x1 = "f`x" and x = "f`y" in bspec [THEN bspec])
```
```   355 apply (safe elim!: bij_is_fun [THEN apply_type])
```
```   356 apply (drule_tac t = "op ` (converse (f))" in subst_context)
```
```   357 apply (simp add: left_inverse_bij)
```
```   358 done
```
```   359
```
```   360 lemma wf_on_ord_iso:
```
```   361     "[| wf[B](s);  f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) |] ==> wf[A](r)"
```
```   362 apply (simp add: wf_on_def wf_def ord_iso_def, safe)
```
```   363 apply (drule_tac x = "{f`z. z:Z \<inter> A}" in spec)
```
```   364 apply (safe intro!: equalityI)
```
```   365 apply (blast dest!: equalityD1 intro: bij_is_fun [THEN apply_type])+
```
```   366 done
```
```   367
```
```   368 lemma well_ord_ord_iso:
```
```   369     "[| well_ord(B,s);  f: ord_iso(A,r,B,s) |] ==> well_ord(A,r)"
```
```   370 apply (unfold well_ord_def tot_ord_def)
```
```   371 apply (fast elim!: part_ord_ord_iso linear_ord_iso wf_on_ord_iso)
```
```   372 done
```
```   373
```
```   374
```
```   375 subsection{*Main results of Kunen, Chapter 1 section 6*}
```
```   376
```
```   377 (*Inductive argument for Kunen's Lemma 6.1, etc.
```
```   378   Simple proof from Halmos, page 72*)
```
```   379 lemma well_ord_iso_subset_lemma:
```
```   380      "[| well_ord(A,r);  f: ord_iso(A,r, A',r);  A'<= A;  y: A |]
```
```   381       ==> ~ <f`y, y>: r"
```
```   382 apply (simp add: well_ord_def ord_iso_def)
```
```   383 apply (elim conjE CollectE)
```
```   384 apply (rule_tac a=y in wf_on_induct, assumption+)
```
```   385 apply (blast dest: bij_is_fun [THEN apply_type])
```
```   386 done
```
```   387
```
```   388 (*Kunen's Lemma 6.1: there's no order-isomorphism to an initial segment
```
```   389                      of a well-ordering*)
```
```   390 lemma well_ord_iso_predE:
```
```   391      "[| well_ord(A,r);  f \<in> ord_iso(A, r, pred(A,x,r), r);  x:A |] ==> P"
```
```   392 apply (insert well_ord_iso_subset_lemma [of A r f "pred(A,x,r)" x])
```
```   393 apply (simp add: pred_subset)
```
```   394 (*Now we know  f`x < x *)
```
```   395 apply (drule ord_iso_is_bij [THEN bij_is_fun, THEN apply_type], assumption)
```
```   396 (*Now we also know @{term"f`x \<in> pred(A,x,r)"}: contradiction! *)
```
```   397 apply (simp add: well_ord_def pred_def)
```
```   398 done
```
```   399
```
```   400 (*Simple consequence of Lemma 6.1*)
```
```   401 lemma well_ord_iso_pred_eq:
```
```   402      "[| well_ord(A,r);  f \<in> ord_iso(pred(A,a,r), r, pred(A,c,r), r);
```
```   403          a:A;  c:A |] ==> a=c"
```
```   404 apply (frule well_ord_is_trans_on)
```
```   405 apply (frule well_ord_is_linear)
```
```   406 apply (erule_tac x=a and y=c in linearE, assumption+)
```
```   407 apply (drule ord_iso_sym)
```
```   408 (*two symmetric cases*)
```
```   409 apply (auto elim!: well_ord_subset [OF _ pred_subset, THEN well_ord_iso_predE]
```
```   410             intro!: predI
```
```   411             simp add: trans_pred_pred_eq)
```
```   412 done
```
```   413
```
```   414 (*Does not assume r is a wellordering!*)
```
```   415 lemma ord_iso_image_pred:
```
```   416      "[|f \<in> ord_iso(A,r,B,s);  a:A|] ==> f `` pred(A,a,r) = pred(B, f`a, s)"
```
```   417 apply (unfold ord_iso_def pred_def)
```
```   418 apply (erule CollectE)
```
```   419 apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: image_fun [OF bij_is_fun Collect_subset])
```
```   420 apply (rule equalityI)
```
```   421 apply (safe elim!: bij_is_fun [THEN apply_type])
```
```   422 apply (rule RepFun_eqI)
```
```   423 apply (blast intro!: right_inverse_bij [symmetric])
```
```   424 apply (auto simp add: right_inverse_bij  bij_is_fun [THEN apply_funtype])
```
```   425 done
```
```   426
```
```   427 lemma ord_iso_restrict_image:
```
```   428      "[| f \<in> ord_iso(A,r,B,s);  C<=A |]
```
```   429       ==> restrict(f,C) \<in> ord_iso(C, r, f``C, s)"
```
```   430 apply (simp add: ord_iso_def)
```
```   431 apply (blast intro: bij_is_inj restrict_bij)
```
```   432 done
```
```   433
```
```   434 (*But in use, A and B may themselves be initial segments.  Then use
```
```   435   trans_pred_pred_eq to simplify the pred(pred...) terms.  See just below.*)
```
```   436 lemma ord_iso_restrict_pred:
```
```   437    "[| f \<in> ord_iso(A,r,B,s);   a:A |]
```
```   438     ==> restrict(f, pred(A,a,r)) \<in> ord_iso(pred(A,a,r), r, pred(B, f`a, s), s)"
```
```   439 apply (simp add: ord_iso_image_pred [symmetric])
```
```   440 apply (blast intro: ord_iso_restrict_image elim: predE)
```
```   441 done
```
```   442
```
```   443 (*Tricky; a lot of forward proof!*)
```
```   444 lemma well_ord_iso_preserving:
```
```   445      "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s);  <a,c>: r;
```
```   446          f \<in> ord_iso(pred(A,a,r), r, pred(B,b,s), s);
```
```   447          g \<in> ord_iso(pred(A,c,r), r, pred(B,d,s), s);
```
```   448          a:A;  c:A;  b:B;  d:B |] ==> <b,d>: s"
```
```   449 apply (frule ord_iso_is_bij [THEN bij_is_fun, THEN apply_type], (erule asm_rl predI predE)+)
```
```   450 apply (subgoal_tac "b = g`a")
```
```   451 apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
```
```   452 apply (rule well_ord_iso_pred_eq, auto)
```
```   453 apply (frule ord_iso_restrict_pred, (erule asm_rl predI)+)
```
```   454 apply (simp add: well_ord_is_trans_on trans_pred_pred_eq)
```
```   455 apply (erule ord_iso_sym [THEN ord_iso_trans], assumption)
```
```   456 done
```
```   457
```
```   458 (*See Halmos, page 72*)
```
```   459 lemma well_ord_iso_unique_lemma:
```
```   460      "[| well_ord(A,r);
```
```   461          f: ord_iso(A,r, B,s);  g: ord_iso(A,r, B,s);  y: A |]
```
```   462       ==> ~ <g`y, f`y> \<in> s"
```
```   463 apply (frule well_ord_iso_subset_lemma)
```
```   464 apply (rule_tac f = "converse (f) " and g = g in ord_iso_trans)
```
```   465 apply auto
```
```   466 apply (blast intro: ord_iso_sym)
```
```   467 apply (frule ord_iso_is_bij [of f])
```
```   468 apply (frule ord_iso_is_bij [of g])
```
```   469 apply (frule ord_iso_converse)
```
```   470 apply (blast intro!: bij_converse_bij
```
```   471              intro: bij_is_fun apply_funtype)+
```
```   472 apply (erule notE)
```
```   473 apply (simp add: left_inverse_bij bij_is_fun comp_fun_apply [of _ A B])
```
```   474 done
```
```   475
```
```   476
```
```   477 (*Kunen's Lemma 6.2: Order-isomorphisms between well-orderings are unique*)
```
```   478 lemma well_ord_iso_unique: "[| well_ord(A,r);
```
```   479          f: ord_iso(A,r, B,s);  g: ord_iso(A,r, B,s) |] ==> f = g"
```
```   480 apply (rule fun_extension)
```
```   481 apply (erule ord_iso_is_bij [THEN bij_is_fun])+
```
```   482 apply (subgoal_tac "f`x \<in> B & g`x \<in> B & linear(B,s)")
```
```   483  apply (simp add: linear_def)
```
```   484  apply (blast dest: well_ord_iso_unique_lemma)
```
```   485 apply (blast intro: ord_iso_is_bij bij_is_fun apply_funtype
```
```   486                     well_ord_is_linear well_ord_ord_iso ord_iso_sym)
```
```   487 done
```
```   488
```
```   489 subsection{*Towards Kunen's Theorem 6.3: Linearity of the Similarity Relation*}
```
```   490
```
```   491 lemma ord_iso_map_subset: "ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s) \<subseteq> A*B"
```
```   492 by (unfold ord_iso_map_def, blast)
```
```   493
```
```   494 lemma domain_ord_iso_map: "domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) \<subseteq> A"
```
```   495 by (unfold ord_iso_map_def, blast)
```
```   496
```
```   497 lemma range_ord_iso_map: "range(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) \<subseteq> B"
```
```   498 by (unfold ord_iso_map_def, blast)
```
```   499
```
```   500 lemma converse_ord_iso_map:
```
```   501     "converse(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) = ord_iso_map(B,s,A,r)"
```
```   502 apply (unfold ord_iso_map_def)
```
```   503 apply (blast intro: ord_iso_sym)
```
```   504 done
```
```   505
```
```   506 lemma function_ord_iso_map:
```
```   507     "well_ord(B,s) ==> function(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s))"
```
```   508 apply (unfold ord_iso_map_def function_def)
```
```   509 apply (blast intro: well_ord_iso_pred_eq ord_iso_sym ord_iso_trans)
```
```   510 done
```
```   511
```
```   512 lemma ord_iso_map_fun: "well_ord(B,s) ==> ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)
```
```   513            \<in> domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) -> range(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s))"
```
```   514 by (simp add: Pi_iff function_ord_iso_map
```
```   515                  ord_iso_map_subset [THEN domain_times_range])
```
```   516
```
```   517 lemma ord_iso_map_mono_map:
```
```   518     "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s) |]
```
```   519      ==> ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)
```
```   520            \<in> mono_map(domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)), r,
```
```   521                       range(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)), s)"
```
```   522 apply (unfold mono_map_def)
```
```   523 apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: ord_iso_map_fun)
```
```   524 apply safe
```
```   525 apply (subgoal_tac "x:A & ya:A & y:B & yb:B")
```
```   526  apply (simp add: apply_equality [OF _  ord_iso_map_fun])
```
```   527  apply (unfold ord_iso_map_def)
```
```   528  apply (blast intro: well_ord_iso_preserving, blast)
```
```   529 done
```
```   530
```
```   531 lemma ord_iso_map_ord_iso:
```
```   532     "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s) |] ==> ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)
```
```   533            \<in> ord_iso(domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)), r,
```
```   534                       range(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)), s)"
```
```   535 apply (rule well_ord_mono_ord_isoI)
```
```   536    prefer 4
```
```   537    apply (rule converse_ord_iso_map [THEN subst])
```
```   538    apply (simp add: ord_iso_map_mono_map
```
```   539                     ord_iso_map_subset [THEN converse_converse])
```
```   540 apply (blast intro!: domain_ord_iso_map range_ord_iso_map
```
```   541              intro: well_ord_subset ord_iso_map_mono_map)+
```
```   542 done
```
```   543
```
```   544
```
```   545 (*One way of saying that domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) is downwards-closed*)
```
```   546 lemma domain_ord_iso_map_subset:
```
```   547      "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s);
```
```   548          a: A;  a \<notin> domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) |]
```
```   549       ==>  domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) \<subseteq> pred(A, a, r)"
```
```   550 apply (unfold ord_iso_map_def)
```
```   551 apply (safe intro!: predI)
```
```   552 (*Case analysis on  xa vs a in r *)
```
```   553 apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
```
```   554 apply (frule_tac A = A in well_ord_is_linear)
```
```   555 apply (rename_tac b y f)
```
```   556 apply (erule_tac x=b and y=a in linearE, assumption+)
```
```   557 (*Trivial case: b=a*)
```
```   558 apply clarify
```
```   559 apply blast
```
```   560 (*Harder case: <a, xa>: r*)
```
```   561 apply (frule ord_iso_is_bij [THEN bij_is_fun, THEN apply_type],
```
```   562        (erule asm_rl predI predE)+)
```
```   563 apply (frule ord_iso_restrict_pred)
```
```   564  apply (simp add: pred_iff)
```
```   565 apply (simp split: split_if_asm
```
```   566           add: well_ord_is_trans_on trans_pred_pred_eq domain_UN domain_Union, blast)
```
```   567 done
```
```   568
```
```   569 (*For the 4-way case analysis in the main result*)
```
```   570 lemma domain_ord_iso_map_cases:
```
```   571      "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s) |]
```
```   572       ==> domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) = A |
```
```   573           (\<exists>x\<in>A. domain(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) = pred(A,x,r))"
```
```   574 apply (frule well_ord_is_wf)
```
```   575 apply (unfold wf_on_def wf_def)
```
```   576 apply (drule_tac x = "A-domain (ord_iso_map (A,r,B,s))" in spec)
```
```   577 apply safe
```
```   578 (*The first case: the domain equals A*)
```
```   579 apply (rule domain_ord_iso_map [THEN equalityI])
```
```   580 apply (erule Diff_eq_0_iff [THEN iffD1])
```
```   581 (*The other case: the domain equals an initial segment*)
```
```   582 apply (blast del: domainI subsetI
```
```   583              elim!: predE
```
```   584              intro!: domain_ord_iso_map_subset
```
```   585              intro: subsetI)+
```
```   586 done
```
```   587
```
```   588 (*As above, by duality*)
```
```   589 lemma range_ord_iso_map_cases:
```
```   590     "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s) |]
```
```   591      ==> range(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) = B |
```
```   592          (\<exists>y\<in>B. range(ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s)) = pred(B,y,s))"
```
```   593 apply (rule converse_ord_iso_map [THEN subst])
```
```   594 apply (simp add: domain_ord_iso_map_cases)
```
```   595 done
```
```   596
```
```   597 text{*Kunen's Theorem 6.3: Fundamental Theorem for Well-Ordered Sets*}
```
```   598 theorem well_ord_trichotomy:
```
```   599    "[| well_ord(A,r);  well_ord(B,s) |]
```
```   600     ==> ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s) \<in> ord_iso(A, r, B, s) |
```
```   601         (\<exists>x\<in>A. ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s) \<in> ord_iso(pred(A,x,r), r, B, s)) |
```
```   602         (\<exists>y\<in>B. ord_iso_map(A,r,B,s) \<in> ord_iso(A, r, pred(B,y,s), s))"
```
```   603 apply (frule_tac B = B in domain_ord_iso_map_cases, assumption)
```
```   604 apply (frule_tac B = B in range_ord_iso_map_cases, assumption)
```
```   605 apply (drule ord_iso_map_ord_iso, assumption)
```
```   606 apply (elim disjE bexE)
```
```   607    apply (simp_all add: bexI)
```
```   608 apply (rule wf_on_not_refl [THEN notE])
```
```   609   apply (erule well_ord_is_wf)
```
```   610  apply assumption
```
```   611 apply (subgoal_tac "<x,y>: ord_iso_map (A,r,B,s) ")
```
```   612  apply (drule rangeI)
```
```   613  apply (simp add: pred_def)
```
```   614 apply (unfold ord_iso_map_def, blast)
```
```   615 done
```
```   616
```
```   617
```
```   618 subsection{*Miscellaneous Results by Krzysztof Grabczewski*}
```
```   619
```
```   620 (** Properties of converse(r) **)
```
```   621
```
```   622 lemma irrefl_converse: "irrefl(A,r) ==> irrefl(A,converse(r))"
```
```   623 by (unfold irrefl_def, blast)
```
```   624
```
```   625 lemma trans_on_converse: "trans[A](r) ==> trans[A](converse(r))"
```
```   626 by (unfold trans_on_def, blast)
```
```   627
```
```   628 lemma part_ord_converse: "part_ord(A,r) ==> part_ord(A,converse(r))"
```
```   629 apply (unfold part_ord_def)
```
```   630 apply (blast intro!: irrefl_converse trans_on_converse)
```
```   631 done
```
```   632
```
```   633 lemma linear_converse: "linear(A,r) ==> linear(A,converse(r))"
```
```   634 by (unfold linear_def, blast)
```
```   635
```
```   636 lemma tot_ord_converse: "tot_ord(A,r) ==> tot_ord(A,converse(r))"
```
```   637 apply (unfold tot_ord_def)
```
```   638 apply (blast intro!: part_ord_converse linear_converse)
```
```   639 done
```
```   640
```
```   641
```
```   642 (** By Krzysztof Grabczewski.
```
```   643     Lemmas involving the first element of a well ordered set **)
```
```   644
```
```   645 lemma first_is_elem: "first(b,B,r) ==> b:B"
```
```   646 by (unfold first_def, blast)
```
```   647
```
```   648 lemma well_ord_imp_ex1_first:
```
```   649         "[| well_ord(A,r); B<=A; B\<noteq>0 |] ==> (EX! b. first(b,B,r))"
```
```   650 apply (unfold well_ord_def wf_on_def wf_def first_def)
```
```   651 apply (elim conjE allE disjE, blast)
```
```   652 apply (erule bexE)
```
```   653 apply (rule_tac a = x in ex1I, auto)
```
```   654 apply (unfold tot_ord_def linear_def, blast)
```
```   655 done
```
```   656
```
```   657 lemma the_first_in:
```
```   658      "[| well_ord(A,r); B<=A; B\<noteq>0 |] ==> (THE b. first(b,B,r)) \<in> B"
```
```   659 apply (drule well_ord_imp_ex1_first, assumption+)
```
```   660 apply (rule first_is_elem)
```
```   661 apply (erule theI)
```
```   662 done
```
```   663
```
```   664
```
```   665 subsection {* Lemmas for the Reflexive Orders *}
```
```   666
```
```   667 lemma subset_vimage_vimage_iff:
```
```   668   "[| Preorder(r); A \<subseteq> field(r); B \<subseteq> field(r) |] ==>
```
```   669   r -`` A \<subseteq> r -`` B \<longleftrightarrow> (\<forall>a\<in>A. \<exists>b\<in>B. <a, b> \<in> r)"
```
```   670   apply (auto simp: subset_def preorder_on_def refl_def vimage_def image_def)
```
```   671    apply blast
```
```   672   unfolding trans_on_def
```
```   673   apply (erule_tac P = "(\<lambda>x. \<forall>y\<in>field(?r).
```
```   674           \<forall>z\<in>field(?r). \<langle>x, y\<rangle> \<in> ?r \<longrightarrow> \<langle>y, z\<rangle> \<in> ?r \<longrightarrow> \<langle>x, z\<rangle> \<in> ?r)" in rev_ballE)
```
```   675     (* instance obtained from proof term generated by best *)
```
```   676    apply best
```
```   677   apply blast
```
```   678   done
```
```   679
```
```   680 lemma subset_vimage1_vimage1_iff:
```
```   681   "[| Preorder(r); a \<in> field(r); b \<in> field(r) |] ==>
```
```   682   r -`` {a} \<subseteq> r -`` {b} \<longleftrightarrow> <a, b> \<in> r"
```
```   683   by (simp add: subset_vimage_vimage_iff)
```
```   684
```
```   685 lemma Refl_antisym_eq_Image1_Image1_iff:
```
```   686   "[| refl(field(r), r); antisym(r); a \<in> field(r); b \<in> field(r) |] ==>
```
```   687   r `` {a} = r `` {b} \<longleftrightarrow> a = b"
```
```   688   apply rule
```
```   689    apply (frule equality_iffD)
```
```   690    apply (drule equality_iffD)
```
```   691    apply (simp add: antisym_def refl_def)
```
```   692    apply best
```
```   693   apply (simp add: antisym_def refl_def)
```
```   694   done
```
```   695
```
```   696 lemma Partial_order_eq_Image1_Image1_iff:
```
```   697   "[| Partial_order(r); a \<in> field(r); b \<in> field(r) |] ==>
```
```   698   r `` {a} = r `` {b} \<longleftrightarrow> a = b"
```
```   699   by (simp add: partial_order_on_def preorder_on_def
```
```   700     Refl_antisym_eq_Image1_Image1_iff)
```
```   701
```
```   702 lemma Refl_antisym_eq_vimage1_vimage1_iff:
```
```   703   "[| refl(field(r), r); antisym(r); a \<in> field(r); b \<in> field(r) |] ==>
```
```   704   r -`` {a} = r -`` {b} \<longleftrightarrow> a = b"
```
```   705   apply rule
```
```   706    apply (frule equality_iffD)
```
```   707    apply (drule equality_iffD)
```
```   708    apply (simp add: antisym_def refl_def)
```
```   709    apply best
```
```   710   apply (simp add: antisym_def refl_def)
```
```   711   done
```
```   712
```
```   713 lemma Partial_order_eq_vimage1_vimage1_iff:
```
```   714   "[| Partial_order(r); a \<in> field(r); b \<in> field(r) |] ==>
```
```   715   r -`` {a} = r -`` {b} \<longleftrightarrow> a = b"
```
```   716   by (simp add: partial_order_on_def preorder_on_def
```
```   717     Refl_antisym_eq_vimage1_vimage1_iff)
```
```   718
```
```   719 end
```