src/HOL/Induct/PropLog.thy
author nipkow
Mon, 02 Jun 2008 13:21:06 +0200
changeset 27034 5257bc7e0c06
parent 24824 b7866aea0815
child 36862 952b2b102a0a
permissions -rw-r--r--
tuned proofs
Ignore whitespace changes - Everywhere: Within whitespace: At end of lines:
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
     1
(*  Title:      HOL/Induct/PropLog.thy
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     2
    ID:         $Id$
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     3
    Author:     Tobias Nipkow
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
     4
    Copyright   1994  TU Muenchen & University of Cambridge
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     5
*)
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     6
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
     7
header {* Meta-theory of propositional logic *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
     8
16417
9bc16273c2d4 migrated theory headers to new format
haftmann
parents: 13075
diff changeset
     9
theory PropLog imports Main begin
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    10
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    11
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    12
  Datatype definition of propositional logic formulae and inductive
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    13
  definition of the propositional tautologies.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    14
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    15
  Inductive definition of propositional logic.  Soundness and
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    16
  completeness w.r.t.\ truth-tables.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    17
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    18
  Prove: If @{text "H |= p"} then @{text "G |= p"} where @{text "G \<in>
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    19
  Fin(H)"}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    20
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    21
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    22
subsection {* The datatype of propositions *}
5184
9b8547a9496a Adapted to new datatype package.
berghofe
parents: 3842
diff changeset
    23
24824
b7866aea0815 avoid unnamed infixes;
wenzelm
parents: 23746
diff changeset
    24
datatype 'a pl =
b7866aea0815 avoid unnamed infixes;
wenzelm
parents: 23746
diff changeset
    25
  false |
b7866aea0815 avoid unnamed infixes;
wenzelm
parents: 23746
diff changeset
    26
  var 'a ("#_" [1000]) |
b7866aea0815 avoid unnamed infixes;
wenzelm
parents: 23746
diff changeset
    27
  imp "'a pl" "'a pl" (infixr "->" 90)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    28
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    29
subsection {* The proof system *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    30
23746
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    31
inductive
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    32
  thms :: "['a pl set, 'a pl] => bool"  (infixl "|-" 50)
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    33
  for H :: "'a pl set"
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    34
  where
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    35
    H [intro]:  "p\<in>H ==> H |- p"
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    36
  | K:          "H |- p->q->p"
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    37
  | S:          "H |- (p->q->r) -> (p->q) -> p->r"
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    38
  | DN:         "H |- ((p->false) -> false) -> p"
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    39
  | MP:         "[| H |- p->q; H |- p |] ==> H |- q"
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    40
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    41
subsection {* The semantics *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    42
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    43
subsubsection {* Semantics of propositional logic. *}
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    44
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    45
consts
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    46
  eval  :: "['a set, 'a pl] => bool"      ("_[[_]]" [100,0] 100)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    47
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    48
primrec     "tt[[false]] = False"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
    49
            "tt[[#v]]    = (v \<in> tt)"
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    50
  eval_imp: "tt[[p->q]]  = (tt[[p]] --> tt[[q]])"
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    51
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    52
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    53
  A finite set of hypotheses from @{text t} and the @{text Var}s in
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    54
  @{text p}.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    55
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    56
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    57
consts
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    58
  hyps  :: "['a pl, 'a set] => 'a pl set"
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    59
5184
9b8547a9496a Adapted to new datatype package.
berghofe
parents: 3842
diff changeset
    60
primrec
10759
994877ee68cb *** empty log message ***
nipkow
parents: 9101
diff changeset
    61
  "hyps false  tt = {}"
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    62
  "hyps (#v)   tt = {if v \<in> tt then #v else #v->false}"
10759
994877ee68cb *** empty log message ***
nipkow
parents: 9101
diff changeset
    63
  "hyps (p->q) tt = hyps p tt Un hyps q tt"
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
    64
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    65
subsubsection {* Logical consequence *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    66
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    67
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    68
  For every valuation, if all elements of @{text H} are true then so
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    69
  is @{text p}.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    70
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    71
19736
wenzelm
parents: 18260
diff changeset
    72
definition
21404
eb85850d3eb7 more robust syntax for definition/abbreviation/notation;
wenzelm
parents: 20503
diff changeset
    73
  sat :: "['a pl set, 'a pl] => bool"   (infixl "|=" 50) where
19736
wenzelm
parents: 18260
diff changeset
    74
    "H |= p  =  (\<forall>tt. (\<forall>q\<in>H. tt[[q]]) --> tt[[p]])"
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    75
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    76
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    77
subsection {* Proof theory of propositional logic *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    78
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    79
lemma thms_mono: "G<=H ==> thms(G) <= thms(H)"
23746
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    80
apply (rule predicate1I)
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    81
apply (erule thms.induct)
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    82
apply (auto intro: thms.intros)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    83
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    84
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    85
lemma thms_I: "H |- p->p"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    86
  -- {*Called @{text I} for Identity Combinator, not for Introduction. *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    87
by (best intro: thms.K thms.S thms.MP)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    88
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    89
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    90
subsubsection {* Weakening, left and right *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    91
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    92
lemma weaken_left: "[| G \<subseteq> H;  G|-p |] ==> H|-p"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    93
  -- {* Order of premises is convenient with @{text THEN} *}
23746
a455e69c31cc Adapted to new inductive definition package.
berghofe
parents: 21404
diff changeset
    94
  by (erule thms_mono [THEN predicate1D])
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    95
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    96
lemmas weaken_left_insert = subset_insertI [THEN weaken_left]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    97
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    98
lemmas weaken_left_Un1  = Un_upper1 [THEN weaken_left]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
    99
lemmas weaken_left_Un2  = Un_upper2 [THEN weaken_left]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   100
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   101
lemma weaken_right: "H |- q ==> H |- p->q"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   102
by (fast intro: thms.K thms.MP)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   103
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   104
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   105
subsubsection {* The deduction theorem *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   106
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   107
theorem deduction: "insert p H |- q  ==>  H |- p->q"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   108
apply (induct set: thms)
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   109
apply (fast intro: thms_I thms.H thms.K thms.S thms.DN
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   110
                   thms.S [THEN thms.MP, THEN thms.MP] weaken_right)+
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   111
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   112
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   113
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   114
subsubsection {* The cut rule *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   115
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   116
lemmas cut = deduction [THEN thms.MP]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   117
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   118
lemmas thms_falseE = weaken_right [THEN thms.DN [THEN thms.MP]]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   119
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   120
lemmas thms_notE = thms.MP [THEN thms_falseE, standard]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   121
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   122
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   123
subsubsection {* Soundness of the rules wrt truth-table semantics *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   124
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   125
theorem soundness: "H |- p ==> H |= p"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   126
apply (unfold sat_def)
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   127
apply (induct set: thms)
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   128
apply auto
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   129
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   130
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   131
subsection {* Completeness *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   132
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   133
subsubsection {* Towards the completeness proof *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   134
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   135
lemma false_imp: "H |- p->false ==> H |- p->q"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   136
apply (rule deduction)
27034
5257bc7e0c06 tuned proofs
nipkow
parents: 24824
diff changeset
   137
apply (metis H insert_iff weaken_left_insert thms_notE)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   138
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   139
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   140
lemma imp_false:
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   141
    "[| H |- p;  H |- q->false |] ==> H |- (p->q)->false"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   142
apply (rule deduction)
27034
5257bc7e0c06 tuned proofs
nipkow
parents: 24824
diff changeset
   143
apply (metis H MP insert_iff weaken_left_insert)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   144
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   145
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   146
lemma hyps_thms_if: "hyps p tt |- (if tt[[p]] then p else p->false)"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   147
  -- {* Typical example of strengthening the induction statement. *}
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   148
apply simp
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   149
apply (induct p)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   150
apply (simp_all add: thms_I thms.H)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   151
apply (blast intro: weaken_left_Un1 weaken_left_Un2 weaken_right
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   152
                    imp_false false_imp)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   153
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   154
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   155
lemma sat_thms_p: "{} |= p ==> hyps p tt |- p"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   156
  -- {* Key lemma for completeness; yields a set of assumptions
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   157
        satisfying @{text p} *}
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   158
apply (unfold sat_def)
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   159
apply (drule spec, erule mp [THEN if_P, THEN subst],
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   160
       rule_tac [2] hyps_thms_if, simp)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   161
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   162
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   163
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   164
  For proving certain theorems in our new propositional logic.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   165
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   166
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   167
declare deduction [intro!]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   168
declare thms.H [THEN thms.MP, intro]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   169
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   170
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   171
  The excluded middle in the form of an elimination rule.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   172
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   173
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   174
lemma thms_excluded_middle: "H |- (p->q) -> ((p->false)->q) -> q"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   175
apply (rule deduction [THEN deduction])
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   176
apply (rule thms.DN [THEN thms.MP], best)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   177
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   178
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   179
lemma thms_excluded_middle_rule:
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   180
    "[| insert p H |- q;  insert (p->false) H |- q |] ==> H |- q"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   181
  -- {* Hard to prove directly because it requires cuts *}
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   182
by (rule thms_excluded_middle [THEN thms.MP, THEN thms.MP], auto)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   183
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   184
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   185
subsection{* Completeness -- lemmas for reducing the set of assumptions*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   186
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   187
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   188
  For the case @{prop "hyps p t - insert #v Y |- p"} we also have @{prop
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   189
  "hyps p t - {#v} \<subseteq> hyps p (t-{v})"}.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   190
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   191
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   192
lemma hyps_Diff: "hyps p (t-{v}) <= insert (#v->false) ((hyps p t)-{#v})"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   193
by (induct p) auto
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   194
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   195
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   196
  For the case @{prop "hyps p t - insert (#v -> Fls) Y |- p"} we also have
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   197
  @{prop "hyps p t-{#v->Fls} \<subseteq> hyps p (insert v t)"}.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   198
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   199
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   200
lemma hyps_insert: "hyps p (insert v t) <= insert (#v) (hyps p t-{#v->false})"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   201
by (induct p) auto
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   202
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   203
text {* Two lemmas for use with @{text weaken_left} *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   204
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   205
lemma insert_Diff_same: "B-C <= insert a (B-insert a C)"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   206
by fast
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   207
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   208
lemma insert_Diff_subset2: "insert a (B-{c}) - D <= insert a (B-insert c D)"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   209
by fast
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   210
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   211
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   212
  The set @{term "hyps p t"} is finite, and elements have the form
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   213
  @{term "#v"} or @{term "#v->Fls"}.
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   214
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   215
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   216
lemma hyps_finite: "finite(hyps p t)"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   217
by (induct p) auto
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   218
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   219
lemma hyps_subset: "hyps p t <= (UN v. {#v, #v->false})"
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   220
by (induct p) auto
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   221
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   222
lemmas Diff_weaken_left = Diff_mono [OF _ subset_refl, THEN weaken_left]
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   223
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   224
subsubsection {* Completeness theorem *}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   225
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   226
text {*
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   227
  Induction on the finite set of assumptions @{term "hyps p t0"}.  We
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   228
  may repeatedly subtract assumptions until none are left!
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   229
*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   230
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   231
lemma completeness_0_lemma:
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   232
    "{} |= p ==> \<forall>t. hyps p t - hyps p t0 |- p"
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   233
apply (rule hyps_subset [THEN hyps_finite [THEN finite_subset_induct]])
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   234
 apply (simp add: sat_thms_p, safe)
16563
a92f96951355 meson method taking an argument list
paulson
parents: 16417
diff changeset
   235
 txt{*Case @{text"hyps p t-insert(#v,Y) |- p"} *}
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   236
 apply (iprover intro: thms_excluded_middle_rule
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   237
                     insert_Diff_same [THEN weaken_left]
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   238
                     insert_Diff_subset2 [THEN weaken_left]
16563
a92f96951355 meson method taking an argument list
paulson
parents: 16417
diff changeset
   239
                     hyps_Diff [THEN Diff_weaken_left])
a92f96951355 meson method taking an argument list
paulson
parents: 16417
diff changeset
   240
txt{*Case @{text"hyps p t-insert(#v -> false,Y) |- p"} *}
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   241
 apply (iprover intro: thms_excluded_middle_rule
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   242
                     insert_Diff_same [THEN weaken_left]
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   243
                     insert_Diff_subset2 [THEN weaken_left]
16563
a92f96951355 meson method taking an argument list
paulson
parents: 16417
diff changeset
   244
                     hyps_insert [THEN Diff_weaken_left])
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   245
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   246
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   247
text{*The base case for completeness*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   248
lemma completeness_0:  "{} |= p ==> {} |- p"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   249
apply (rule Diff_cancel [THEN subst])
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   250
apply (erule completeness_0_lemma [THEN spec])
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   251
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   252
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   253
text{*A semantic analogue of the Deduction Theorem*}
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   254
lemma sat_imp: "insert p H |= q ==> H |= p->q"
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   255
by (unfold sat_def, auto)
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   256
18260
5597cfcecd49 tuned induct proofs;
wenzelm
parents: 17589
diff changeset
   257
theorem completeness: "finite H ==> H |= p ==> H |- p"
20503
503ac4c5ef91 induct method: renamed 'fixing' to 'arbitrary';
wenzelm
parents: 19736
diff changeset
   258
apply (induct arbitrary: p rule: finite_induct)
16563
a92f96951355 meson method taking an argument list
paulson
parents: 16417
diff changeset
   259
 apply (blast intro: completeness_0)
17589
58eeffd73be1 renamed rules to iprover
nipkow
parents: 16563
diff changeset
   260
apply (iprover intro: sat_imp thms.H insertI1 weaken_left_insert [THEN thms.MP])
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   261
done
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   262
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   263
theorem syntax_iff_semantics: "finite H ==> (H |- p) = (H |= p)"
16563
a92f96951355 meson method taking an argument list
paulson
parents: 16417
diff changeset
   264
by (blast intro: soundness completeness)
13075
d3e1d554cd6d conversion of some HOL/Induct proof scripts to Isar
paulson
parents: 10759
diff changeset
   265
3120
c58423c20740 New directory to contain examples of (co)inductive definitions
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   266
end