src/HOL/Tools/Old_Datatype/old_datatype.ML

tuned signature;

(*  Title:      HOL/Tools/Old_Datatype/old_datatype.ML
    Author:     Stefan Berghofer, TU Muenchen

Datatype package: definitional introduction of datatypes
with proof of characteristic theorems: injectivity / distinctness
of constructors and induction.  Main interface to datatypes
after full bootstrap of datatype package.
*)

signature OLD_DATATYPE =
sig
  include OLD_DATATYPE_COMMON

  val distinct_lemma: thm
  type spec_cmd =
    (binding * (string * string option) list * mixfix) * (binding * string list * mixfix) list
  val read_specs: spec_cmd list -> theory -> spec list * Proof.context
  val check_specs: spec list -> theory -> spec list * Proof.context
  val add_datatype: config -> spec list -> theory -> string list * theory
  val add_datatype_cmd: config -> spec_cmd list -> theory -> string list * theory
  val spec_cmd: spec_cmd parser
end;

structure Old_Datatype : OLD_DATATYPE =
struct

(** auxiliary **)

val distinct_lemma = @{lemma "f x \<noteq> f y ==> x \<noteq> y" by iprover};
val (_ $ (_ $ (_ $ (distinct_f $ _) $ _))) = hd (Thm.prems_of distinct_lemma);

fun exh_thm_of (dt_info : Old_Datatype_Aux.info Symtab.table) tname =
  #exhaust (the (Symtab.lookup dt_info tname));

val In0_inject = @{thm In0_inject};
val In1_inject = @{thm In1_inject};
val Scons_inject = @{thm Scons_inject};
val Leaf_inject = @{thm Leaf_inject};
val In0_eq = @{thm In0_eq};
val In1_eq = @{thm In1_eq};
val In0_not_In1 = @{thm In0_not_In1};
val In1_not_In0 = @{thm In1_not_In0};
val Lim_inject = @{thm Lim_inject};
val Inl_inject = @{thm Inl_inject};
val Inr_inject = @{thm Inr_inject};
val Suml_inject = @{thm Suml_inject};
val Sumr_inject = @{thm Sumr_inject};

val datatype_injI =
  @{lemma "(!!x. ALL y. f x = f y --> x = y) ==> inj f" by (simp add: inj_on_def)};


(** proof of characteristic theorems **)

fun representation_proofs (config : Old_Datatype_Aux.config)
    (dt_info : Old_Datatype_Aux.info Symtab.table) descr types_syntax constr_syntax case_names_induct
    thy =
  let
    val descr' = flat descr;
    val new_type_names = map (Binding.name_of o fst) types_syntax;
    val big_name = space_implode "_" new_type_names;
    val thy1 = Sign.add_path big_name thy;
    val big_rec_name = "rep_set_" ^ big_name;
    val rep_set_names' =
      if length descr' = 1 then [big_rec_name]
      else map (prefix (big_rec_name ^ "_") o string_of_int) (1 upto length descr');
    val rep_set_names = map (Sign.full_bname thy1) rep_set_names';

    val tyvars = map (fn (_, (_, Ts, _)) => map Old_Datatype_Aux.dest_DtTFree Ts) (hd descr);
    val leafTs' = Old_Datatype_Aux.get_nonrec_types descr';
    val branchTs = Old_Datatype_Aux.get_branching_types descr';
    val branchT =
      if null branchTs then HOLogic.unitT
      else Balanced_Tree.make (fn (T, U) => Type (@{type_name Sum_Type.sum}, [T, U])) branchTs;
    val arities = remove (op =) 0 (Old_Datatype_Aux.get_arities descr');
    val unneeded_vars =
      subtract (op =) (fold Term.add_tfreesT (leafTs' @ branchTs) []) (hd tyvars);
    val leafTs = leafTs' @ map TFree unneeded_vars;
    val recTs = Old_Datatype_Aux.get_rec_types descr';
    val (newTs, oldTs) = chop (length (hd descr)) recTs;
    val sumT =
      if null leafTs then HOLogic.unitT
      else Balanced_Tree.make (fn (T, U) => Type (@{type_name Sum_Type.sum}, [T, U])) leafTs;
    val Univ_elT = HOLogic.mk_setT (Type (@{type_name Old_Datatype.node}, [sumT, branchT]));
    val UnivT = HOLogic.mk_setT Univ_elT;
    val UnivT' = Univ_elT --> HOLogic.boolT;
    val Collect = Const (@{const_name Collect}, UnivT' --> UnivT);

    val In0 = Const (@{const_name Old_Datatype.In0}, Univ_elT --> Univ_elT);
    val In1 = Const (@{const_name Old_Datatype.In1}, Univ_elT --> Univ_elT);
    val Leaf = Const (@{const_name Old_Datatype.Leaf}, sumT --> Univ_elT);
    val Lim = Const (@{const_name Old_Datatype.Lim}, (branchT --> Univ_elT) --> Univ_elT);

    (* make injections needed for embedding types in leaves *)

    fun mk_inj T' x =
      let
        fun mk_inj' T n i =
          if n = 1 then x
          else
            let
              val n2 = n div 2;
              val Type (_, [T1, T2]) = T;
            in
              if i <= n2
              then Const (@{const_name Inl}, T1 --> T) $ mk_inj' T1 n2 i
              else Const (@{const_name Inr}, T2 --> T) $ mk_inj' T2 (n - n2) (i - n2)
            end;
      in mk_inj' sumT (length leafTs) (1 + find_index (fn T'' => T'' = T') leafTs) end;

    (* make injections for constructors *)

    fun mk_univ_inj ts = Balanced_Tree.access
      {left = fn t => In0 $ t,
        right = fn t => In1 $ t,
        init =
          if ts = [] then Const (@{const_name undefined}, Univ_elT)
          else foldr1 (HOLogic.mk_binop @{const_name Old_Datatype.Scons}) ts};

    (* function spaces *)

    fun mk_fun_inj T' x =
      let
        fun mk_inj T n i =
          if n = 1 then x
          else
            let
              val n2 = n div 2;
              val Type (_, [T1, T2]) = T;
              fun mkT U = (U --> Univ_elT) --> T --> Univ_elT;
            in
              if i <= n2 then Const (@{const_name Sum_Type.Suml}, mkT T1) $ mk_inj T1 n2 i
              else Const (@{const_name Sum_Type.Sumr}, mkT T2) $ mk_inj T2 (n - n2) (i - n2)
            end;
      in mk_inj branchT (length branchTs) (1 + find_index (fn T'' => T'' = T') branchTs) end;

    fun mk_lim t Ts = fold_rev (fn T => fn t => Lim $ mk_fun_inj T (Abs ("x", T, t))) Ts t;

    (************** generate introduction rules for representing set **********)

    val _ = Old_Datatype_Aux.message config "Constructing representing sets ...";

    (* make introduction rule for a single constructor *)

    fun make_intr s n (i, (_, cargs)) =
      let
        fun mk_prem dt (j, prems, ts) =
          (case Old_Datatype_Aux.strip_dtyp dt of
            (dts, Old_Datatype_Aux.DtRec k) =>
              let
                val Ts = map (Old_Datatype_Aux.typ_of_dtyp descr') dts;
                val free_t =
                  Old_Datatype_Aux.app_bnds (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" (Ts ---> Univ_elT) j)
                    (length Ts)
              in
                (j + 1, Logic.list_all (map (pair "x") Ts,
                  HOLogic.mk_Trueprop
                    (Free (nth rep_set_names' k, UnivT') $ free_t)) :: prems,
                mk_lim free_t Ts :: ts)
              end
          | _ =>
              let val T = Old_Datatype_Aux.typ_of_dtyp descr' dt
              in (j + 1, prems, (Leaf $ mk_inj T (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T j)) :: ts) end);

        val (_, prems, ts) = fold_rev mk_prem cargs (1, [], []);
        val concl = HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (Free (s, UnivT') $ mk_univ_inj ts n i);
      in Logic.list_implies (prems, concl) end;

    val intr_ts = maps (fn ((_, (_, _, constrs)), rep_set_name) =>
      map (make_intr rep_set_name (length constrs))
        ((1 upto length constrs) ~~ constrs)) (descr' ~~ rep_set_names');

    val ({raw_induct = rep_induct, intrs = rep_intrs, ...}, thy2) =
      thy1
      |> Sign.concealed
      |> Inductive.add_inductive_global
          {quiet_mode = #quiet config, verbose = false, alt_name = Binding.name big_rec_name,
           coind = false, no_elim = true, no_ind = false, skip_mono = true}
          (map (fn s => ((Binding.name s, UnivT'), NoSyn)) rep_set_names') []
          (map (fn x => (Attrib.empty_binding, x)) intr_ts) []
      ||> Sign.restore_naming thy1;

    (********************************* typedef ********************************)

    val (typedefs, thy3) = thy2
      |> Sign.parent_path
      |> fold_map
        (fn (((name, mx), tvs), c) =>
          Typedef.add_typedef_global false (name, tvs, mx)
            (Collect $ Const (c, UnivT')) NONE
            (fn ctxt =>
              resolve_tac ctxt [exI] 1 THEN
              resolve_tac ctxt [CollectI] 1 THEN
              QUIET_BREADTH_FIRST (has_fewer_prems 1)
              (resolve_tac ctxt rep_intrs 1)))
        (types_syntax ~~ tyvars ~~ take (length newTs) rep_set_names)
      ||> Sign.add_path big_name;

    (*********************** definition of constructors ***********************)

    val big_rep_name = big_name ^ "_Rep_";
    val rep_names' = map (fn i => big_rep_name ^ string_of_int i) (1 upto length (flat (tl descr)));
    val all_rep_names =
      map (#Rep_name o #1 o #2) typedefs @
      map (Sign.full_bname thy3) rep_names';

    (* isomorphism declarations *)

    val iso_decls = map (fn (T, s) => (Binding.name s, T --> Univ_elT, NoSyn))
      (oldTs ~~ rep_names');

    (* constructor definitions *)

    fun make_constr_def (typedef: Typedef.info) T n
        ((cname, cargs), (cname', mx)) (thy, defs, eqns, i) =
      let
        fun constr_arg dt (j, l_args, r_args) =
          let
            val T = Old_Datatype_Aux.typ_of_dtyp descr' dt;
            val free_t = Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T j;
          in
            (case (Old_Datatype_Aux.strip_dtyp dt, strip_type T) of
              ((_, Old_Datatype_Aux.DtRec m), (Us, U)) =>
                (j + 1, free_t :: l_args, mk_lim
                  (Const (nth all_rep_names m, U --> Univ_elT) $
                    Old_Datatype_Aux.app_bnds free_t (length Us)) Us :: r_args)
            | _ => (j + 1, free_t :: l_args, (Leaf $ mk_inj T free_t) :: r_args))
          end;

        val (_, l_args, r_args) = fold_rev constr_arg cargs (1, [], []);
        val constrT = map (Old_Datatype_Aux.typ_of_dtyp descr') cargs ---> T;
        val ({Abs_name, Rep_name, ...}, _) = typedef;
        val lhs = list_comb (Const (cname, constrT), l_args);
        val rhs = mk_univ_inj r_args n i;
        val def = Logic.mk_equals (lhs, Const (Abs_name, Univ_elT --> T) $ rhs);
        val def_name = Thm.def_name (Long_Name.base_name cname);
        val eqn =
          HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (HOLogic.mk_eq (Const (Rep_name, T --> Univ_elT) $ lhs, rhs));
        val ([def_thm], thy') =
          thy
          |> Sign.add_consts [(cname', constrT, mx)]
          |> (Global_Theory.add_defs false o map Thm.no_attributes) [(Binding.name def_name, def)];

      in (thy', defs @ [def_thm], eqns @ [eqn], i + 1) end;

    (* constructor definitions for datatype *)

    fun dt_constr_defs (((((_, (_, _, constrs)), tname), typedef: Typedef.info), T), constr_syntax)
        (thy, defs, eqns, rep_congs, dist_lemmas) =
      let
        val ctxt = Proof_Context.init_global thy;
        val _ $ (_ $ (cong_f $ _) $ _) = Thm.concl_of arg_cong;
        val rep_const = Thm.cterm_of ctxt (Const (#Rep_name (#1 typedef), T --> Univ_elT));
        val cong' = infer_instantiate ctxt [(#1 (dest_Var cong_f), rep_const)] arg_cong;
        val dist = infer_instantiate ctxt [(#1 (dest_Var distinct_f), rep_const)] distinct_lemma;
        val (thy', defs', eqns', _) =
          fold (make_constr_def typedef T (length constrs))
            (constrs ~~ constr_syntax) (Sign.add_path tname thy, defs, [], 1);
      in
        (Sign.parent_path thy', defs', eqns @ [eqns'],
          rep_congs @ [cong'], dist_lemmas @ [dist])
      end;

    val (thy4, constr_defs, constr_rep_eqns, rep_congs, dist_lemmas) =
      fold dt_constr_defs
        (hd descr ~~ new_type_names ~~ map #2 typedefs ~~ newTs ~~ constr_syntax)
        (thy3 |> Sign.add_consts iso_decls |> Sign.parent_path, [], [], [], []);


    (*********** isomorphisms for new types (introduced by typedef) ***********)

    val _ = Old_Datatype_Aux.message config "Proving isomorphism properties ...";

    val collect_simp = rewrite_rule (Proof_Context.init_global thy4) [mk_meta_eq mem_Collect_eq];

    val newT_iso_axms = typedefs |> map (fn (_, (_, {Abs_inverse, Rep_inverse, Rep, ...})) =>
      (collect_simp Abs_inverse, Rep_inverse, collect_simp Rep));

    val newT_iso_inj_thms = typedefs |> map (fn (_, (_, {Abs_inject, Rep_inject, ...})) =>
      (collect_simp Abs_inject RS iffD1, Rep_inject RS iffD1));

    (********* isomorphisms between existing types and "unfolded" types *******)

    (*---------------------------------------------------------------------*)
    (* isomorphisms are defined using primrec-combinators:                 *)
    (* generate appropriate functions for instantiating primrec-combinator *)
    (*                                                                     *)
    (*   e.g.  Rep_dt_i = list_rec ... (%h t y. In1 (Scons (Leaf h) y))    *)
    (*                                                                     *)
    (* also generate characteristic equations for isomorphisms             *)
    (*                                                                     *)
    (*   e.g.  Rep_dt_i (cons h t) = In1 (Scons (Rep_dt_j h) (Rep_dt_i t)) *)
    (*---------------------------------------------------------------------*)

    fun make_iso_def k ks n (cname, cargs) (fs, eqns, i) =
      let
        val argTs = map (Old_Datatype_Aux.typ_of_dtyp descr') cargs;
        val T = nth recTs k;
        val rep_const = Const (nth all_rep_names k, T --> Univ_elT);
        val constr = Const (cname, argTs ---> T);

        fun process_arg ks' dt (i2, i2', ts, Ts) =
          let
            val T' = Old_Datatype_Aux.typ_of_dtyp descr' dt;
            val (Us, U) = strip_type T'
          in
            (case Old_Datatype_Aux.strip_dtyp dt of
              (_, Old_Datatype_Aux.DtRec j) =>
                if member (op =) ks' j then
                  (i2 + 1, i2' + 1, ts @ [mk_lim (Old_Datatype_Aux.app_bnds
                     (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "y" (Us ---> Univ_elT) i2') (length Us)) Us],
                   Ts @ [Us ---> Univ_elT])
                else
                  (i2 + 1, i2', ts @ [mk_lim
                     (Const (nth all_rep_names j, U --> Univ_elT) $
                        Old_Datatype_Aux.app_bnds
                          (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T' i2) (length Us)) Us], Ts)
            | _ => (i2 + 1, i2', ts @ [Leaf $ mk_inj T' (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T' i2)], Ts))
          end;

        val (i2, i2', ts, Ts) = fold (process_arg ks) cargs (1, 1, [], []);
        val xs = map (uncurry (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x")) (argTs ~~ (1 upto (i2 - 1)));
        val ys = map (uncurry (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "y")) (Ts ~~ (1 upto (i2' - 1)));
        val f = fold_rev lambda (xs @ ys) (mk_univ_inj ts n i);

        val (_, _, ts', _) = fold (process_arg []) cargs (1, 1, [], []);
        val eqn = HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (HOLogic.mk_eq
          (rep_const $ list_comb (constr, xs), mk_univ_inj ts' n i))

      in (fs @ [f], eqns @ [eqn], i + 1) end;

    (* define isomorphisms for all mutually recursive datatypes in list ds *)

    fun make_iso_defs ds (thy, char_thms) =
      let
        val ks = map fst ds;
        val (_, (tname, _, _)) = hd ds;
        val {rec_rewrites, rec_names, ...} = the (Symtab.lookup dt_info tname);

        fun process_dt (k, (_, _, constrs)) (fs, eqns, isos) =
          let
            val (fs', eqns', _) = fold (make_iso_def k ks (length constrs)) constrs (fs, eqns, 1);
            val iso = (nth recTs k, nth all_rep_names k);
          in (fs', eqns', isos @ [iso]) end;

        val (fs, eqns, isos) = fold process_dt ds ([], [], []);
        val fTs = map fastype_of fs;
        val defs =
          map (fn (rec_name, (T, iso_name)) =>
            (Binding.name (Thm.def_name (Long_Name.base_name iso_name)),
              Logic.mk_equals (Const (iso_name, T --> Univ_elT),
                list_comb (Const (rec_name, fTs @ [T] ---> Univ_elT), fs)))) (rec_names ~~ isos);
        val (def_thms, thy') =
          (Global_Theory.add_defs false o map Thm.no_attributes) defs thy;

        (* prove characteristic equations *)

        val rewrites = def_thms @ map mk_meta_eq rec_rewrites;
        val char_thms' =
          map (fn eqn => Goal.prove_sorry_global thy' [] [] eqn
            (fn {context = ctxt, ...} =>
              EVERY [rewrite_goals_tac ctxt rewrites, resolve_tac ctxt [refl] 1])) eqns;

      in (thy', char_thms' @ char_thms) end;

    val (thy5, iso_char_thms) =
      fold_rev make_iso_defs (tl descr) (Sign.add_path big_name thy4, []);

    (* prove isomorphism properties *)

    fun mk_funs_inv thy thm =
      let
        val prop = Thm.prop_of thm;
        val _ $ (_ $ ((S as Const (_, Type (_, [U, _]))) $ _ )) $
          (_ $ (_ $ (r $ (a $ _)) $ _)) = Type.legacy_freeze prop;
        val used = Term.add_tfree_names a [];

        fun mk_thm i =
          let
            val Ts = map (TFree o rpair @{sort type}) (Name.variant_list used (replicate i "'t"));
            val f = Free ("f", Ts ---> U);
          in
            Goal.prove_sorry_global thy [] []
              (Logic.mk_implies
                (HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (HOLogic.list_all
                   (map (pair "x") Ts, S $ Old_Datatype_Aux.app_bnds f i)),
                 HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (HOLogic.mk_eq (fold_rev (Term.abs o pair "x") Ts
                   (r $ (a $ Old_Datatype_Aux.app_bnds f i)), f))))
              (fn {context = ctxt, ...} =>
                EVERY [REPEAT_DETERM_N i (resolve_tac ctxt @{thms ext} 1),
                 REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt [allE] 1),
                 resolve_tac ctxt [thm] 1,
                 assume_tac ctxt 1])
          end
      in map (fn r => r RS subst) (thm :: map mk_thm arities) end;

    (* prove  inj Rep_dt_i  and  Rep_dt_i x : rep_set_dt_i *)

    val fun_congs =
      map (fn T => make_elim (Thm.instantiate' [SOME (Thm.global_ctyp_of thy5 T)] [] fun_cong)) branchTs;

    fun prove_iso_thms ds (inj_thms, elem_thms) =
      let
        val (_, (tname, _, _)) = hd ds;
        val induct = #induct (the (Symtab.lookup dt_info tname));

        fun mk_ind_concl (i, _) =
          let
            val T = nth recTs i;
            val Rep_t = Const (nth all_rep_names i, T --> Univ_elT);
            val rep_set_name = nth rep_set_names i;
            val concl1 =
              HOLogic.all_const T $ Abs ("y", T, HOLogic.imp $
                HOLogic.mk_eq (Rep_t $ Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T i, Rep_t $ Bound 0) $
                  HOLogic.mk_eq (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T i, Bound 0));
            val concl2 = Const (rep_set_name, UnivT') $ (Rep_t $ Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T i);
          in (concl1, concl2) end;

        val (ind_concl1, ind_concl2) = split_list (map mk_ind_concl ds);

        val rewrites = map mk_meta_eq iso_char_thms;
        val inj_thms' = map snd newT_iso_inj_thms @ map (fn r => r RS @{thm injD}) inj_thms;

        val inj_thm =
          Goal.prove_sorry_global thy5 [] []
            (HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_conj ind_concl1))
            (fn {context = ctxt, ...} => EVERY
              [(Old_Datatype_Aux.ind_tac ctxt induct [] THEN_ALL_NEW
                  Object_Logic.atomize_prems_tac ctxt) 1,
               REPEAT (EVERY
                 [resolve_tac ctxt [allI] 1, resolve_tac ctxt [impI] 1,
                  Old_Datatype_Aux.exh_tac ctxt (exh_thm_of dt_info) 1,
                  REPEAT (EVERY
                    [hyp_subst_tac ctxt 1,
                     rewrite_goals_tac ctxt rewrites,
                     REPEAT (dresolve_tac ctxt [In0_inject, In1_inject] 1),
                     (eresolve_tac ctxt [In0_not_In1 RS notE, In1_not_In0 RS notE] 1)
                     ORELSE (EVERY
                       [REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt (Scons_inject ::
                          map make_elim [Leaf_inject, Inl_inject, Inr_inject]) 1),
                        REPEAT (cong_tac ctxt 1), resolve_tac ctxt [refl] 1,
                        REPEAT (assume_tac ctxt 1 ORELSE (EVERY
                          [REPEAT (resolve_tac ctxt @{thms ext} 1),
                           REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt (mp :: allE ::
                             map make_elim (Suml_inject :: Sumr_inject ::
                               Lim_inject :: inj_thms') @ fun_congs) 1),
                           assume_tac ctxt 1]))])])])]);

        val inj_thms'' = map (fn r => r RS datatype_injI) (Old_Datatype_Aux.split_conj_thm inj_thm);

        val elem_thm =
          Goal.prove_sorry_global thy5 [] []
            (HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_conj ind_concl2))
            (fn {context = ctxt, ...} =>
              EVERY [
                (Old_Datatype_Aux.ind_tac ctxt induct [] THEN_ALL_NEW
                  Object_Logic.atomize_prems_tac ctxt) 1,
                rewrite_goals_tac ctxt rewrites,
                REPEAT ((resolve_tac ctxt rep_intrs THEN_ALL_NEW
                  ((REPEAT o eresolve_tac ctxt [allE]) THEN' ares_tac ctxt elem_thms)) 1)]);

      in (inj_thms'' @ inj_thms, elem_thms @ Old_Datatype_Aux.split_conj_thm elem_thm) end;

    val (iso_inj_thms_unfolded, iso_elem_thms) =
      fold_rev prove_iso_thms (tl descr) ([], map #3 newT_iso_axms);
    val iso_inj_thms =
      map snd newT_iso_inj_thms @ map (fn r => r RS @{thm injD}) iso_inj_thms_unfolded;

    (* prove  rep_set_dt_i x --> x : range Rep_dt_i *)

    fun mk_iso_t (((set_name, iso_name), i), T) =
      let val isoT = T --> Univ_elT in
        HOLogic.imp $
          (Const (set_name, UnivT') $ Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" Univ_elT i) $
            (if i < length newTs then @{term True}
             else HOLogic.mk_mem (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" Univ_elT i,
               Const (@{const_name image}, isoT --> HOLogic.mk_setT T --> UnivT) $
                 Const (iso_name, isoT) $ Const (@{const_abbrev UNIV}, HOLogic.mk_setT T)))
      end;

    val iso_t = HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_conj (map mk_iso_t
      (rep_set_names ~~ all_rep_names ~~ (0 upto (length descr' - 1)) ~~ recTs)));

    (* all the theorems are proved by one single simultaneous induction *)

    val range_eqs = map (fn r => mk_meta_eq (r RS @{thm range_ex1_eq})) iso_inj_thms_unfolded;

    val iso_thms =
      if length descr = 1 then []
      else
        drop (length newTs) (Old_Datatype_Aux.split_conj_thm
          (Goal.prove_sorry_global thy5 [] [] iso_t (fn {context = ctxt, ...} => EVERY
             [(Old_Datatype_Aux.ind_tac ctxt rep_induct [] THEN_ALL_NEW
                 Object_Logic.atomize_prems_tac ctxt) 1,
              REPEAT (resolve_tac ctxt [TrueI] 1),
              rewrite_goals_tac ctxt (mk_meta_eq @{thm choice_eq} ::
                Thm.symmetric (mk_meta_eq @{thm fun_eq_iff}) :: range_eqs),
              rewrite_goals_tac ctxt (map Thm.symmetric range_eqs),
              REPEAT (EVERY
                [REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt ([rangeE, @{thm ex1_implies_ex} RS exE] @
                   maps (mk_funs_inv thy5 o #1) newT_iso_axms) 1),
                 TRY (hyp_subst_tac ctxt 1),
                 resolve_tac ctxt [sym RS range_eqI] 1,
                 resolve_tac ctxt iso_char_thms 1])])));

    val Abs_inverse_thms' =
      map #1 newT_iso_axms @
      map2 (fn r_inj => fn r => @{thm f_the_inv_into_f} OF [r_inj, r RS mp])
        iso_inj_thms_unfolded iso_thms;

    val Abs_inverse_thms = maps (mk_funs_inv thy5) Abs_inverse_thms';

    (******************* freeness theorems for constructors *******************)

    val _ = Old_Datatype_Aux.message config "Proving freeness of constructors ...";

    (* prove theorem  Rep_i (Constr_j ...) = Inj_j ...  *)

    fun prove_constr_rep_thm eqn =
      let
        val inj_thms = map fst newT_iso_inj_thms;
        val rewrites = @{thm o_def} :: constr_defs @ map (mk_meta_eq o #2) newT_iso_axms;
      in
        Goal.prove_sorry_global thy5 [] [] eqn
        (fn {context = ctxt, ...} => EVERY
          [resolve_tac ctxt inj_thms 1,
           rewrite_goals_tac ctxt rewrites,
           resolve_tac ctxt [refl] 3,
           resolve_tac ctxt rep_intrs 2,
           REPEAT (resolve_tac ctxt iso_elem_thms 1)])
      end;

    (*--------------------------------------------------------------*)
    (* constr_rep_thms and rep_congs are used to prove distinctness *)
    (* of constructors.                                             *)
    (*--------------------------------------------------------------*)

    val constr_rep_thms = map (map prove_constr_rep_thm) constr_rep_eqns;

    val dist_rewrites =
      map (fn (rep_thms, dist_lemma) =>
        dist_lemma :: (rep_thms @ [In0_eq, In1_eq, In0_not_In1, In1_not_In0]))
          (constr_rep_thms ~~ dist_lemmas);

    fun prove_distinct_thms dist_rewrites' =
      let
        fun prove [] = []
          | prove (t :: ts) =
              let
                val dist_thm = Goal.prove_sorry_global thy5 [] [] t (fn {context = ctxt, ...} =>
                  EVERY [simp_tac (put_simpset HOL_ss ctxt addsimps dist_rewrites') 1])
              in dist_thm :: Drule.zero_var_indexes (dist_thm RS not_sym) :: prove ts end;
      in prove end;

    val distinct_thms =
      map2 (prove_distinct_thms) dist_rewrites (Old_Datatype_Prop.make_distincts descr);

    (* prove injectivity of constructors *)

    fun prove_constr_inj_thm rep_thms t =
      let
        val inj_thms = Scons_inject ::
          map make_elim
            (iso_inj_thms @
              [In0_inject, In1_inject, Leaf_inject, Inl_inject, Inr_inject,
               Lim_inject, Suml_inject, Sumr_inject])
      in
        Goal.prove_sorry_global thy5 [] [] t
          (fn {context = ctxt, ...} => EVERY
            [resolve_tac ctxt [iffI] 1,
             REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt [conjE] 2), hyp_subst_tac ctxt 2,
             resolve_tac ctxt [refl] 2,
             dresolve_tac ctxt rep_congs 1,
             dresolve_tac ctxt @{thms box_equals} 1,
             REPEAT (resolve_tac ctxt rep_thms 1),
             REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt inj_thms 1),
             REPEAT (ares_tac ctxt [conjI] 1 ORELSE (EVERY [REPEAT (resolve_tac ctxt @{thms ext} 1),
               REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt (make_elim fun_cong :: inj_thms) 1),
               assume_tac ctxt 1]))])
      end;

    val constr_inject =
      map (fn (ts, thms) => map (prove_constr_inj_thm thms) ts)
        (Old_Datatype_Prop.make_injs descr ~~ constr_rep_thms);

    val ((constr_inject', distinct_thms'), thy6) =
      thy5
      |> Sign.parent_path
      |> Old_Datatype_Aux.store_thmss "inject" new_type_names constr_inject
      ||>> Old_Datatype_Aux.store_thmss "distinct" new_type_names distinct_thms;

    (*************************** induction theorem ****************************)

    val _ = Old_Datatype_Aux.message config "Proving induction rule for datatypes ...";

    val Rep_inverse_thms =
      map (fn (_, iso, _) => iso RS subst) newT_iso_axms @
      map (fn r => r RS @{thm the_inv_f_f} RS subst) iso_inj_thms_unfolded;
    val Rep_inverse_thms' = map (fn r => r RS @{thm the_inv_f_f}) iso_inj_thms_unfolded;

    fun mk_indrule_lemma (i, _) T =
      let
        val Rep_t = Const (nth all_rep_names i, T --> Univ_elT) $ Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T i;
        val Abs_t =
          if i < length newTs then
            Const (#Abs_name (#1 (#2 (nth typedefs i))), Univ_elT --> T)
          else
            Const (@{const_name the_inv_into},
              [HOLogic.mk_setT T, T --> Univ_elT, Univ_elT] ---> T) $
            HOLogic.mk_UNIV T $ Const (nth all_rep_names i, T --> Univ_elT);
        val prem =
          HOLogic.imp $
            (Const (nth rep_set_names i, UnivT') $ Rep_t) $
              (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "P" (T --> HOLogic.boolT) (i + 1) $ (Abs_t $ Rep_t));
        val concl =
          Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "P" (T --> HOLogic.boolT) (i + 1) $
            Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_Free "x" T i;
      in (prem, concl) end;

    val (indrule_lemma_prems, indrule_lemma_concls) =
      split_list (map2 mk_indrule_lemma descr' recTs);

    val indrule_lemma =
      Goal.prove_sorry_global thy6 [] []
        (Logic.mk_implies
          (HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_conj indrule_lemma_prems),
           HOLogic.mk_Trueprop (Old_Datatype_Aux.mk_conj indrule_lemma_concls)))
        (fn {context = ctxt, ...} =>
          EVERY
           [REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt [conjE] 1),
            REPEAT (EVERY
              [TRY (resolve_tac ctxt [conjI] 1), resolve_tac ctxt Rep_inverse_thms 1,
               eresolve_tac ctxt [mp] 1, resolve_tac ctxt iso_elem_thms 1])]);

    val Ps = map head_of (HOLogic.dest_conj (HOLogic.dest_Trueprop (Thm.concl_of indrule_lemma)));
    val frees =
      if length Ps = 1 then [Free ("P", snd (dest_Var (hd Ps)))]
      else map (Free o apfst fst o dest_Var) Ps;

    val dt_induct_prop = Old_Datatype_Prop.make_ind descr;
    val dt_induct =
      Goal.prove_sorry_global thy6 []
      (Logic.strip_imp_prems dt_induct_prop)
      (Logic.strip_imp_concl dt_induct_prop)
      (fn {context = ctxt, prems, ...} =>
        let
          val indrule_lemma' =
            infer_instantiate ctxt
              (map (#1 o dest_Var) Ps ~~ map (Thm.cterm_of ctxt) frees) indrule_lemma;
        in
          EVERY
            [resolve_tac ctxt [indrule_lemma'] 1,
             (Old_Datatype_Aux.ind_tac ctxt rep_induct [] THEN_ALL_NEW
                Object_Logic.atomize_prems_tac ctxt) 1,
             EVERY (map (fn (prem, r) => (EVERY
               [REPEAT (eresolve_tac ctxt Abs_inverse_thms 1),
                simp_tac (put_simpset HOL_basic_ss ctxt
                  addsimps (Thm.symmetric r :: Rep_inverse_thms')) 1,
                DEPTH_SOLVE_1 (ares_tac ctxt [prem] 1 ORELSE eresolve_tac ctxt [allE] 1)]))
                    (prems ~~ (constr_defs @ map mk_meta_eq iso_char_thms)))]
        end);

    val ([(_, [dt_induct'])], thy7) =
      thy6
      |> Global_Theory.note_thmss ""
        [((Binding.qualify true big_name (Binding.name "induct"), [case_names_induct]),
          [([dt_induct], [])])];
  in
    ((constr_inject', distinct_thms', dt_induct'), thy7)
  end;



(** datatype definition **)

(* specifications *)

type spec_cmd =
  (binding * (string * string option) list * mixfix) * (binding * string list * mixfix) list;

local

fun parse_spec ctxt ((b, args, mx), constrs) =
  ((b, map (apsnd (Typedecl.read_constraint ctxt)) args, mx),
    constrs |> map (fn (c, Ts, mx') => (c, map (Syntax.parse_typ ctxt) Ts, mx')));

fun check_specs ctxt (specs: Old_Datatype_Aux.spec list) =
  let
    fun prep_spec ((tname, args, mx), constrs) tys =
      let
        val (args', tys1) = chop (length args) tys;
        val (constrs', tys3) = (constrs, tys1) |-> fold_map (fn (cname, cargs, mx') => fn tys2 =>
          let val (cargs', tys3) = chop (length cargs) tys2;
          in ((cname, cargs', mx'), tys3) end);
      in (((tname, map dest_TFree args', mx), constrs'), tys3) end;

    val all_tys =
      specs |> maps (fn ((_, args, _), cs) => map TFree args @ maps #2 cs)
      |> Syntax.check_typs ctxt;

  in #1 (fold_map prep_spec specs all_tys) end;

fun prep_specs parse raw_specs thy =
  let
    val ctxt = thy
      |> Sign.add_types_global (map (fn ((b, args, mx), _) => (b, length args, mx)) raw_specs)
      |> Proof_Context.init_global
      |> fold (fn ((_, args, _), _) => fold (fn (a, _) =>
          Variable.declare_typ (TFree (a, dummyS))) args) raw_specs;
    val specs = check_specs ctxt (map (parse ctxt) raw_specs);
  in (specs, ctxt) end;

in

val read_specs = prep_specs parse_spec;
val check_specs = prep_specs (K I);

end;


(* main commands *)

fun gen_add_datatype prep_specs config raw_specs thy =
  let
    val (dts, spec_ctxt) = prep_specs raw_specs thy;
    val ((_, tyvars, _), _) :: _ = dts;
    val string_of_tyvar = Syntax.string_of_typ spec_ctxt o TFree;

    val (new_dts, types_syntax) = dts |> map (fn ((tname, tvs, mx), _) =>
      let val full_tname = Sign.full_name thy tname in
        (case duplicates (op =) tvs of
          [] =>
            if eq_set (op =) (tyvars, tvs) then ((full_tname, tvs), (tname, mx))
            else error "Mutually recursive datatypes must have same type parameters"
        | dups =>
            error ("Duplicate parameter(s) for datatype " ^ Binding.print tname ^
              " : " ^ commas (map string_of_tyvar dups)))
      end) |> split_list;
    val dt_names = map fst new_dts;

    val _ =
      (case duplicates (op =) (map fst new_dts) of
        [] => ()
      | dups => error ("Duplicate datatypes: " ^ commas_quote dups));

    fun prep_dt_spec ((tname, tvs, _), constrs) (dts', constr_syntax, i) =
      let
        fun prep_constr (cname, cargs, mx) (constrs, constr_syntax') =
          let
            val _ =
              (case subtract (op =) tvs (fold Term.add_tfreesT cargs []) of
                [] => ()
              | vs => error ("Extra type variables on rhs: " ^ commas (map string_of_tyvar vs)));
            val c = Sign.full_name_path thy (Binding.name_of tname) cname;
          in
            (constrs @ [(c, map (Old_Datatype_Aux.dtyp_of_typ new_dts) cargs)],
              constr_syntax' @ [(cname, mx)])
          end handle ERROR msg =>
            cat_error msg ("The error above occurred in constructor " ^ Binding.print cname ^
              " of datatype " ^ Binding.print tname);

        val (constrs', constr_syntax') = fold prep_constr constrs ([], []);
      in
        (case duplicates (op =) (map fst constrs') of
          [] =>
            (dts' @ [(i, (Sign.full_name thy tname, map Old_Datatype_Aux.DtTFree tvs, constrs'))],
              constr_syntax @ [constr_syntax'], i + 1)
        | dups =>
            error ("Duplicate constructors " ^ commas_quote dups ^
              " in datatype " ^ Binding.print tname))
      end;

    val (dts', constr_syntax, i) = fold prep_dt_spec dts ([], [], 0);

    val dt_info = Old_Datatype_Data.get_all thy;
    val (descr, _) = Old_Datatype_Aux.unfold_datatypes spec_ctxt dts' dt_info dts' i;
    val _ =
      Old_Datatype_Aux.check_nonempty descr
        handle (exn as Old_Datatype_Aux.Datatype_Empty s) =>
          if #strict config then error ("Nonemptiness check failed for datatype " ^ quote s)
          else reraise exn;

    val _ =
      Old_Datatype_Aux.message config
        ("Constructing datatype(s) " ^ commas_quote (map (Binding.name_of o #1 o #1) dts));
  in
    thy
    |> representation_proofs config dt_info descr types_syntax constr_syntax
      (Old_Datatype_Data.mk_case_names_induct (flat descr))
    |-> (fn (inject, distinct, induct) =>
      Old_Rep_Datatype.derive_datatype_props config dt_names descr induct inject distinct)
  end;

val add_datatype = gen_add_datatype check_specs;
val add_datatype_cmd = gen_add_datatype read_specs;


(* outer syntax *)

val spec_cmd =
  Parse.type_args_constrained -- Parse.binding -- Parse.opt_mixfix --
  (@{keyword "="} |-- Parse.enum1 "|" (Parse.binding -- Scan.repeat Parse.typ -- Parse.opt_mixfix))
  >> (fn (((vs, t), mx), cons) => ((t, vs, mx), map Parse.triple1 cons));

val _ =
  Outer_Syntax.command @{command_keyword old_datatype} "define old-style inductive datatypes"
    (Parse.and_list1 spec_cmd
      >> (Toplevel.theory o (snd oo add_datatype_cmd Old_Datatype_Aux.default_config)));

open Old_Datatype_Aux;

end;