# HG changeset patch
# User paulson
# Date 1229007002 0
# Node ID a624dc56e85907c6e1dbc959f33601d0521b9ffa
# Parent  b9c5726e79ab66744a854c8335ef10399e9419c2# Parent  13c2670f9865ae676895b003812253824ee7b211
Automated merge with ssh://paulson@atbroy100.informatik.tu-muenchen.de//home/isabelle-repository/repos/isabelle

diff -r b9c5726e79ab -r a624dc56e859 src/HOL/MetisExamples/Abstraction.thy
--- a/src/HOL/MetisExamples/Abstraction.thy	Thu Dec 11 09:02:22 2008 +0100
+++ b/src/HOL/MetisExamples/Abstraction.thy	Thu Dec 11 14:50:02 2008 +0000
@@ -62,9 +62,9 @@
 
 ML{*AtpWrapper.problem_name := "Abstraction__Sigma_Collect"*}
 lemma "(a,b) \<in> (SIGMA x: A. {y. x = f y}) ==> a \<in> A & a = f b"
-(*???metis cannot prove this
-by (metis CollectD SigmaD1 SigmaD2 UN_eq)
-Also, UN_eq is unnecessary*)
+(*???metis says this is satisfiable!
+by (metis CollectD SigmaD1 SigmaD2)
+*)
 by (meson CollectD SigmaD1 SigmaD2)
 
 
diff -r b9c5726e79ab -r a624dc56e859 src/HOL/Tools/res_clause.ML
--- a/src/HOL/Tools/res_clause.ML	Thu Dec 11 09:02:22 2008 +0100
+++ b/src/HOL/Tools/res_clause.ML	Thu Dec 11 14:50:02 2008 +0000
@@ -279,6 +279,14 @@
 (*Given a list of sorted type variables, return a list of type literals.*)
 fun add_typs Ts = foldl (op union) [] (map sorts_on_typs Ts);
 
+(*The correct treatment of TFrees like 'a in lemmas (axiom clauses) is not clear.
+  * Ignoring them leads to unsound proofs, since we do nothing to ensure that 'a
+    in a lemma has the same sort as 'a in the conjecture.
+  * Deleting such clauses will lead to problems with locales in other use of local results
+    where 'a is fixed. Probably we should delete clauses unless the sorts agree.
+  * Currently we include a class constraint in the clause, exactly as with TVars.
+*)
+
 (** make axiom and conjecture clauses. **)
 
 fun get_tvar_strs [] = []