src/HOL/Probability/Central_Limit_Theorem.thy

explicit predicate for confined bit range avoids cyclic rewriting in presence of extensionality rule for bit values (contributed by Thomas Sewell)

(*  Title:     HOL/Probability/Central_Limit_Theorem.thy
    Authors:   Jeremy Avigad (CMU), Luke Serafin (CMU)
*)

section \<open>The Central Limit Theorem\<close>

theory Central_Limit_Theorem
  imports Levy
begin

theorem (in prob_space) central_limit_theorem_zero_mean:
  fixes X :: "nat \<Rightarrow> 'a \<Rightarrow> real"
    and \<mu> :: "real measure"
    and \<sigma> :: real
    and S :: "nat \<Rightarrow> 'a \<Rightarrow> real"
  assumes X_indep: "indep_vars (\<lambda>i. borel) X UNIV"
    and X_mean_0: "\<And>n. expectation (X n) = 0"
    and \<sigma>_pos: "\<sigma> > 0"
    and X_square_integrable: "\<And>n. integrable M (\<lambda>x. (X n x)\<^sup>2)"
    and X_variance: "\<And>n. variance (X n) = \<sigma>\<^sup>2"
    and X_distrib: "\<And>n. distr M borel (X n) = \<mu>"
  defines "S n \<equiv> \<lambda>x. \<Sum>i<n. X i x"
  shows "weak_conv_m (\<lambda>n. distr M borel (\<lambda>x. S n x / sqrt (n * \<sigma>\<^sup>2))) std_normal_distribution"
proof -
  let ?S' = "\<lambda>n x. S n x / sqrt (real n * \<sigma>\<^sup>2)"
  define \<phi> where "\<phi> n = char (distr M borel (?S' n))" for n
  define \<psi> where "\<psi> n t = char \<mu> (t / sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * n))" for n t

  have X_rv [simp, measurable]: "random_variable borel (X n)" for n
    using X_indep unfolding indep_vars_def2 by simp
  have X_integrable [simp, intro]: "integrable M (X n)" for n
    by (rule square_integrable_imp_integrable[OF _ X_square_integrable]) simp_all
  interpret \<mu>: real_distribution \<mu>
    by (subst X_distrib [symmetric, of 0], rule real_distribution_distr, simp)

  (* these are equivalent to the hypotheses on X, given X_distr *)
  have \<mu>_integrable [simp]: "integrable \<mu> (\<lambda>x. x)"
    and \<mu>_mean_integrable [simp]: "\<mu>.expectation (\<lambda>x. x) = 0"
    and \<mu>_square_integrable [simp]: "integrable \<mu> (\<lambda>x. x^2)"
    and \<mu>_variance [simp]: "\<mu>.expectation (\<lambda>x. x^2) = \<sigma>\<^sup>2"
    using assms by (simp_all add: X_distrib [symmetric, of 0] integrable_distr_eq integral_distr)

  have main: "\<forall>\<^sub>F n in sequentially.
      cmod (\<phi> n t - (1 + (-(t^2) / 2) / n)^n) \<le>
      t\<^sup>2 / (6 * \<sigma>\<^sup>2) * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>t / sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * n)\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3))" for t
  proof (rule eventually_sequentiallyI)
    fix n :: nat
    assume "n \<ge> nat (ceiling (t^2 / 4))"
    hence n: "n \<ge> t^2 / 4" by (subst nat_ceiling_le_eq [symmetric])
    let ?t = "t / sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * n)"

    define \<psi>' where "\<psi>' n i = char (distr M borel (\<lambda>x. X i x / sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * n)))" for n i
    have *: "\<And>n i t. \<psi>' n i t = \<psi> n t"
      unfolding \<psi>_def \<psi>'_def char_def
      by (subst X_distrib [symmetric]) (auto simp: integral_distr)

    have "\<phi> n t = char (distr M borel (\<lambda>x. \<Sum>i<n. X i x / sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * real n))) t"
      by (auto simp: \<phi>_def S_def sum_divide_distrib ac_simps)
    also have "\<dots> = (\<Prod> i < n. \<psi>' n i t)"
      unfolding \<psi>'_def
      apply (rule char_distr_sum)
      apply (rule indep_vars_compose2[where X=X])
      apply (rule indep_vars_subset)
      apply (rule X_indep)
      apply auto
      done
    also have "\<dots> = (\<psi> n t)^n"
      by (auto simp add: * prod_constant)
    finally have \<phi>_eq: "\<phi> n t =(\<psi> n t)^n" .

    have "norm (\<psi> n t - (1 - ?t^2 * \<sigma>\<^sup>2 / 2)) \<le> ?t\<^sup>2 / 6 * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3))"
      unfolding \<psi>_def by (rule \<mu>.char_approx3, auto)
    also have "?t^2 * \<sigma>\<^sup>2 = t^2 / n"
      using \<sigma>_pos by (simp add: power_divide)
    also have "t^2 / n / 2 = (t^2 / 2) / n"
      by simp
    finally have **: "norm (\<psi> n t - (1 + (-(t^2) / 2) / n)) \<le>
      ?t\<^sup>2 / 6 * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3))" by simp

    have "norm (\<phi> n t - (complex_of_real (1 + (-(t^2) / 2) / n))^n) \<le>
         n * norm (\<psi> n t - (complex_of_real (1 + (-(t^2) / 2) / n)))"
      using n
      by (auto intro!: norm_power_diff \<mu>.cmod_char_le_1 abs_leI
               simp del: of_real_diff simp: of_real_diff[symmetric] divide_le_eq \<phi>_eq \<psi>_def)
    also have "\<dots> \<le> n * (?t\<^sup>2 / 6 * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3)))"
      by (rule mult_left_mono [OF **], simp)
    also have "\<dots> = (t\<^sup>2 / (6 * \<sigma>\<^sup>2) * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3)))"
      using \<sigma>_pos by (simp add: field_simps min_absorb2)
    finally show "norm (\<phi> n t - (1 + (-(t^2) / 2) / n)^n) \<le>
        (t\<^sup>2 / (6 * \<sigma>\<^sup>2) * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3)))"
      by simp
  qed

  show ?thesis
  proof (rule levy_continuity)
    fix t
    let ?t = "\<lambda>n. t / sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * n)"
    have "\<And>x. (\<lambda>n. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>t\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3 / \<bar>sqrt (\<sigma>\<^sup>2 * real n)\<bar>)) \<longlonglongrightarrow> 0"
      using \<sigma>_pos
      by (auto simp: real_sqrt_mult min_absorb2
               intro!: tendsto_min[THEN tendsto_eq_rhs] sqrt_at_top[THEN filterlim_compose]
                       filterlim_tendsto_pos_mult_at_top filterlim_at_top_imp_at_infinity
                       tendsto_divide_0 filterlim_real_sequentially)
    then have "(\<lambda>n. LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t n\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3)) \<longlonglongrightarrow> (LINT x|\<mu>. 0)"
      by (intro integral_dominated_convergence [where w = "\<lambda>x. 6 * x^2"]) auto
    then have *: "(\<lambda>n. t\<^sup>2 / (6 * \<sigma>\<^sup>2) * (LINT x|\<mu>. min (6 * x\<^sup>2) (\<bar>?t n\<bar> * \<bar>x\<bar> ^ 3))) \<longlonglongrightarrow> 0"
      by (simp only: integral_zero tendsto_mult_right_zero)

    have "(\<lambda>n. complex_of_real ((1 + (-(t^2) / 2) / n)^n)) \<longlonglongrightarrow> complex_of_real (exp (-(t^2) / 2))"
      by (rule isCont_tendsto_compose [OF _ tendsto_exp_limit_sequentially]) auto
    then have "(\<lambda>n. \<phi> n t) \<longlonglongrightarrow> complex_of_real (exp (-(t^2) / 2))"
      by (rule Lim_transform) (rule Lim_null_comparison [OF main *])
    then show "(\<lambda>n. char (distr M borel (?S' n)) t) \<longlonglongrightarrow> char std_normal_distribution t"
      by (simp add: \<phi>_def char_std_normal_distribution)
  qed (auto intro!: real_dist_normal_dist simp: S_def)
qed

theorem (in prob_space) central_limit_theorem:
  fixes X :: "nat \<Rightarrow> 'a \<Rightarrow> real"
    and \<mu> :: "real measure"
    and \<sigma> :: real
    and S :: "nat \<Rightarrow> 'a \<Rightarrow> real"
  assumes X_indep: "indep_vars (\<lambda>i. borel) X UNIV"
    and X_mean: "\<And>n. expectation (X n) = m"
    and \<sigma>_pos: "\<sigma> > 0"
    and X_square_integrable: "\<And>n. integrable M (\<lambda>x. (X n x)\<^sup>2)"
    and X_variance: "\<And>n. variance (X n) = \<sigma>\<^sup>2"
    and X_distrib: "\<And>n. distr M borel (X n) = \<mu>"
  defines "X' i x \<equiv> X i x - m"
  shows "weak_conv_m (\<lambda>n. distr M borel (\<lambda>x. (\<Sum>i<n. X' i x) / sqrt (n*\<sigma>\<^sup>2))) std_normal_distribution"
proof (intro central_limit_theorem_zero_mean)
  show "indep_vars (\<lambda>i. borel) X' UNIV"
    unfolding X'_def[abs_def] using X_indep by (rule indep_vars_compose2) auto
  have X_rv [simp, measurable]: "random_variable borel (X n)" for n
    using X_indep unfolding indep_vars_def2 by simp
  have X_integrable [simp, intro]: "integrable M (X n)" for n
    by (rule square_integrable_imp_integrable[OF _ X_square_integrable]) simp_all
  show "expectation (X' n) = 0" for n
    using X_mean by (auto simp: X'_def[abs_def] prob_space)
  show "\<sigma> > 0" "integrable M (\<lambda>x. (X' n x)\<^sup>2)" "variance (X' n) = \<sigma>\<^sup>2" for n
    using \<open>0 < \<sigma>\<close> X_integrable X_mean X_square_integrable X_variance unfolding X'_def
    by (auto simp: prob_space power2_diff)
  show "distr M borel (X' n) = distr \<mu> borel (\<lambda>x. x - m)" for n
    unfolding X_distrib[of n, symmetric] using X_integrable
    by (subst distr_distr) (auto simp: X'_def[abs_def] comp_def)
qed

end