doc-src/TutorialI/Inductive/Advanced.thy
author berghofe
Thu, 13 Sep 2001 16:26:16 +0200
changeset 11563 e172cbed431d
parent 11173 094b76968484
child 11711 ecdfd237ffee
permissions -rw-r--r--
Fixed proof term bug in permute_prems.
Ignore whitespace changes - Everywhere: Within whitespace: At end of lines:
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
     1
(* ID:         $Id$ *)
10426
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
     2
theory Advanced = Even:
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
     3
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
     4
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
     5
datatype 'f gterm = Apply 'f "'f gterm list"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
     6
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
     7
datatype integer_op = Number int | UnaryMinus | Plus;
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
     8
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
     9
consts gterms :: "'f set \<Rightarrow> 'f gterm set"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    10
inductive "gterms F"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    11
intros
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    12
step[intro!]: "\<lbrakk>\<forall>t \<in> set args. t \<in> gterms F;  f \<in> F\<rbrakk>
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    13
               \<Longrightarrow> (Apply f args) \<in> gterms F"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    14
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    15
lemma gterms_mono: "F\<subseteq>G \<Longrightarrow> gterms F \<subseteq> gterms G"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    16
apply clarify
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    17
apply (erule gterms.induct)
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    18
txt{*
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    19
@{subgoals[display,indent=0,margin=65]}
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    20
*};
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    21
apply blast
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    22
done
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    23
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    24
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    25
text{*
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    26
@{thm[display] even.cases[no_vars]}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    27
\rulename{even.cases}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    28
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    29
Just as a demo I include
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    30
the two forms that Markus has made available. First the one for binding the
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    31
result to a name 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    32
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    33
*}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    34
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    35
inductive_cases Suc_Suc_cases [elim!]:
10426
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
    36
  "Suc(Suc n) \<in> even"
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
    37
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    38
thm Suc_Suc_cases;
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    39
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    40
text{*
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    41
@{thm[display] Suc_Suc_cases[no_vars]}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    42
\rulename{Suc_Suc_cases}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    43
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    44
and now the one for local usage:
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    45
*}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    46
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    47
lemma "Suc(Suc n) \<in> even \<Longrightarrow> P n";
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    48
apply (ind_cases "Suc(Suc n) \<in> even");
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    49
oops
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    50
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    51
inductive_cases gterm_Apply_elim [elim!]: "Apply f args \<in> gterms F"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    52
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    53
text{*this is what we get:
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    54
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    55
@{thm[display] gterm_Apply_elim[no_vars]}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    56
\rulename{gterm_Apply_elim}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    57
*}
10426
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
    58
11173
094b76968484 revisions in response to comments by Tobias
paulson
parents: 10882
diff changeset
    59
lemma gterms_IntI [rule_format, intro!]:
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    60
     "t \<in> gterms F \<Longrightarrow> t \<in> gterms G \<longrightarrow> t \<in> gterms (F\<inter>G)"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    61
apply (erule gterms.induct)
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    62
txt{*
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    63
@{subgoals[display,indent=0,margin=65]}
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
    64
*};
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    65
apply blast
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    66
done
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    67
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    68
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    69
text{*
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    70
@{thm[display] mono_Int[no_vars]}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    71
\rulename{mono_Int}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    72
*}
10426
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
    73
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    74
lemma gterms_Int_eq [simp]:
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    75
     "gterms (F\<inter>G) = gterms F \<inter> gterms G"
11173
094b76968484 revisions in response to comments by Tobias
paulson
parents: 10882
diff changeset
    76
by (blast intro!: mono_Int monoI gterms_mono)
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    77
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    78
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    79
consts integer_arity :: "integer_op \<Rightarrow> nat"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    80
primrec
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    81
"integer_arity (Number n)        = #0"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    82
"integer_arity UnaryMinus        = #1"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    83
"integer_arity Plus              = #2"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    84
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    85
consts well_formed_gterm :: "('f \<Rightarrow> nat) \<Rightarrow> 'f gterm set"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    86
inductive "well_formed_gterm arity"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    87
intros
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    88
step[intro!]: "\<lbrakk>\<forall>t \<in> set args. t \<in> well_formed_gterm arity;  
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    89
                length args = arity f\<rbrakk>
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    90
               \<Longrightarrow> (Apply f args) \<in> well_formed_gterm arity"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    91
10426
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
    92
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    93
consts well_formed_gterm' :: "('f \<Rightarrow> nat) \<Rightarrow> 'f gterm set"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    94
inductive "well_formed_gterm' arity"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    95
intros
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    96
step[intro!]: "\<lbrakk>args \<in> lists (well_formed_gterm' arity);  
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    97
                length args = arity f\<rbrakk>
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    98
               \<Longrightarrow> (Apply f args) \<in> well_formed_gterm' arity"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
    99
monos lists_mono
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   100
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   101
lemma "well_formed_gterm arity \<subseteq> well_formed_gterm' arity"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   102
apply clarify
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   103
txt{*
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   104
The situation after clarify
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   105
@{subgoals[display,indent=0,margin=65]}
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   106
*};
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   107
apply (erule well_formed_gterm.induct)
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   108
txt{*
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   109
note the induction hypothesis!
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   110
@{subgoals[display,indent=0,margin=65]}
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   111
*};
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   112
apply auto
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   113
done
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   114
10426
469f19c4bf97 rule inversion
nipkow
parents: 10370
diff changeset
   115
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   116
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   117
lemma "well_formed_gterm' arity \<subseteq> well_formed_gterm arity"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   118
apply clarify
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   119
txt{*
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   120
The situation after clarify
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   121
@{subgoals[display,indent=0,margin=65]}
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   122
*};
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   123
apply (erule well_formed_gterm'.induct)
10882
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   124
txt{*
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   125
note the induction hypothesis!
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   126
@{subgoals[display,indent=0,margin=65]}
ca41ba5fb8e2 updated for new version of advanced-examples.tex
paulson
parents: 10468
diff changeset
   127
*};
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   128
apply auto
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   129
done
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   130
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   131
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   132
text{*
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   133
@{thm[display] lists_Int_eq[no_vars]}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   134
*}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   135
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   136
text{* the rest isn't used: too complicated.  OK for an exercise though.*}
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   137
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   138
consts integer_signature :: "(integer_op * (unit list * unit)) set"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   139
inductive "integer_signature"
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   140
intros
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   141
Number:     "(Number n,   ([], ())) \<in> integer_signature"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   142
UnaryMinus: "(UnaryMinus, ([()], ())) \<in> integer_signature"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   143
Plus:       "(Plus,       ([(),()], ())) \<in> integer_signature"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   144
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   145
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   146
consts well_typed_gterm :: "('f \<Rightarrow> 't list * 't) \<Rightarrow> ('f gterm * 't)set"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   147
inductive "well_typed_gterm sig"
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   148
intros
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   149
step[intro!]: 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   150
    "\<lbrakk>\<forall>pair \<in> set args. pair \<in> well_typed_gterm sig; 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   151
      sig f = (map snd args, rtype)\<rbrakk>
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   152
     \<Longrightarrow> (Apply f (map fst args), rtype) 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   153
         \<in> well_typed_gterm sig"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   154
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   155
consts well_typed_gterm' :: "('f \<Rightarrow> 't list * 't) \<Rightarrow> ('f gterm * 't)set"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   156
inductive "well_typed_gterm' sig"
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   157
intros
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   158
step[intro!]: 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   159
    "\<lbrakk>args \<in> lists(well_typed_gterm' sig); 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   160
      sig f = (map snd args, rtype)\<rbrakk>
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   161
     \<Longrightarrow> (Apply f (map fst args), rtype) 
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   162
         \<in> well_typed_gterm' sig"
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   163
monos lists_mono
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   164
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   165
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   166
lemma "well_typed_gterm sig \<subseteq> well_typed_gterm' sig"
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   167
apply clarify
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   168
apply (erule well_typed_gterm.induct)
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   169
apply auto
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   170
done
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   171
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   172
lemma "well_typed_gterm' sig \<subseteq> well_typed_gterm sig"
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   173
apply clarify
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   174
apply (erule well_typed_gterm'.induct)
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   175
apply auto
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   176
done
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   177
10468
87dda999deca first version of Advanced Inductive Defs section
paulson
parents: 10426
diff changeset
   178
10370
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   179
end
99bd3e902979 advanced induction examples
paulson
parents:
diff changeset
   180