src/HOL/MicroJava/Comp/CorrComp.thy

Adjusted to new map update priorities

(*  Title:      HOL/MicroJava/Comp/CorrComp.thy
    Author:     Martin Strecker
*)

(* Compiler correctness statement and proof *)

theory CorrComp
imports "../J/JTypeSafe" LemmasComp
begin

declare wf_prog_ws_prog [simp add]

(* If no exception is present after evaluation/execution, 
  none can have been present before *)
lemma eval_evals_exec_xcpt:
 "(G \<turnstile> xs -ex\<succ>val-> xs' \<longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<longrightarrow> gx xs = None) \<and>
  (G \<turnstile> xs -exs[\<succ>]vals-> xs' \<longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<longrightarrow> gx xs = None) \<and>
  (G \<turnstile> xs -st-> xs' \<longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<longrightarrow> gx xs = None)"
  by (induct rule: eval_evals_exec.induct) auto


(* instance of eval_evals_exec_xcpt for eval *)
lemma eval_xcpt: "G \<turnstile> xs -ex\<succ>val-> xs' \<Longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<Longrightarrow> gx xs = None"
 (is "?H1 \<Longrightarrow> ?H2 \<Longrightarrow> ?T")
proof-
  assume h1: ?H1
  assume h2: ?H2
  from h1 h2 eval_evals_exec_xcpt show "?T" by simp
qed

(* instance of eval_evals_exec_xcpt for evals *)
lemma evals_xcpt: "G \<turnstile> xs -exs[\<succ>]vals-> xs' \<Longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<Longrightarrow> gx xs = None"
 (is "?H1 \<Longrightarrow> ?H2 \<Longrightarrow> ?T")
proof-
  assume h1: ?H1
  assume h2: ?H2
  from h1 h2 eval_evals_exec_xcpt show "?T" by simp
qed

(* instance of eval_evals_exec_xcpt for exec *)
lemma exec_xcpt: "G \<turnstile> xs -st-> xs' \<Longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<Longrightarrow> gx xs = None"
 (is "?H1 \<Longrightarrow> ?H2 \<Longrightarrow> ?T")
proof-
  assume h1: ?H1
  assume h2: ?H2
  from h1 h2 eval_evals_exec_xcpt show "?T" by simp
qed

(**********************************************************************)

theorem exec_all_trans: "\<lbrakk>(exec_all G s0 s1); (exec_all G s1 s2)\<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> (exec_all G s0 s2)"
 by (auto simp: exec_all_def elim: Transitive_Closure.rtrancl_trans)

theorem exec_all_refl: "exec_all G s s"
 by (simp only: exec_all_def)


theorem exec_instr_in_exec_all:
  "\<lbrakk> exec_instr i G hp stk lvars C S pc frs =  (None, hp', frs');
             gis (gmb G C S) ! pc = i\<rbrakk>  \<Longrightarrow>
       G \<turnstile> (None, hp, (stk, lvars, C, S, pc) # frs) \<midarrow>jvm\<rightarrow> (None, hp', frs')"
  apply (simp only: exec_all_def)
  apply (rule rtrancl_refl [THEN rtrancl_into_rtrancl])
  apply (simp add: gis_def gmb_def)
  apply (case_tac frs', simp+)
  done

theorem exec_all_one_step: "
  \<lbrakk> gis (gmb G C S) = pre @ (i # post); pc0 = length pre;
  (exec_instr i G hp0 stk0 lvars0 C S pc0 frs) = 
  (None, hp1, (stk1,lvars1,C,S, Suc pc0)#frs) \<rbrakk>
  \<Longrightarrow> 
  G \<turnstile> (None, hp0, (stk0,lvars0,C,S, pc0)#frs) \<midarrow>jvm\<rightarrow> 
  (None, hp1, (stk1,lvars1,C,S, Suc pc0)#frs)"
  apply (unfold exec_all_def)
  apply (rule r_into_rtrancl)
  apply (simp add: gis_def gmb_def split_beta)
  done


(***********************************************************************)

definition progression :: "jvm_prog \<Rightarrow> cname \<Rightarrow> sig \<Rightarrow> 
                 aheap \<Rightarrow> opstack \<Rightarrow> locvars \<Rightarrow>
                 bytecode \<Rightarrow>
                 aheap \<Rightarrow> opstack \<Rightarrow> locvars \<Rightarrow> 
                 bool"
  ("{_,_,_} \<turnstile> {_, _, _} >- _ \<rightarrow> {_, _, _}" [61,61,61,61,61,61,90,61,61,61]60) where
  "{G,C,S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- instrs \<rightarrow> {hp1, os1, lvars1} ==
  \<forall>pre post frs.
  (gis (gmb G C S) = pre @ instrs @ post) \<longrightarrow>
   G \<turnstile> (None,hp0,(os0,lvars0,C,S,length pre)#frs) \<midarrow>jvm\<rightarrow>
       (None,hp1,(os1,lvars1,C,S,(length pre) + (length instrs))#frs)"



lemma progression_call: 
  "\<lbrakk> \<forall>pc frs.
  exec_instr instr G hp0 os0 lvars0 C S pc frs =
      (None, hp', (os', lvars', C', S', 0) # (fr pc) # frs) \<and> 
  gis (gmb G C' S') = instrs' @ [Return] \<and> 
  {G, C', S'} \<turnstile> {hp', os', lvars'} >- instrs' \<rightarrow> {hp'', os'', lvars''}  \<and>
  exec_instr Return G hp'' os'' lvars'' C' S' (length instrs') 
                                               ((fr pc) # frs) =
      (None, hp2, (os2, lvars2, C, S, Suc pc) # frs) \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow>
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >-[instr]\<rightarrow> {hp2,os2,lvars2}"
  apply (simp only: progression_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (drule_tac x="length pre" in spec)
  apply (drule_tac x="frs" in spec)
  apply clarify
  apply (rule exec_all_trans)
   apply (rule exec_instr_in_exec_all)
    apply simp
   apply simp
  apply (rule exec_all_trans)
   apply (simp only: append_Nil)
   apply (drule_tac x="[]" in spec)
   apply (simp only: list.simps list.size)
   apply blast
  apply (rule exec_instr_in_exec_all)
   apply auto
  done


lemma progression_transitive: 
  "\<lbrakk> instrs_comb = instrs0 @ instrs1; 
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- instrs0 \<rightarrow> {hp1, os1, lvars1};
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp1, os1, lvars1} >- instrs1 \<rightarrow> {hp2, os2, lvars2} \<rbrakk>
  \<Longrightarrow>
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- instrs_comb \<rightarrow> {hp2, os2, lvars2}"
  apply (simp only: progression_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (rule_tac ?s1.0 = "Norm (hp1, (os1, lvars1, C, S,
                           length pre + length instrs0) # frs)"  
               in exec_all_trans)
   apply (simp only: append_assoc)
  apply (erule thin_rl, erule thin_rl)
  apply (drule_tac x="pre @ instrs0" in spec)
  apply (simp add: add.assoc)
  done

lemma progression_refl: 
  "{G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- [] \<rightarrow> {hp0, os0, lvars0}"
  apply (simp add: progression_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (rule exec_all_refl)
  done

lemma progression_one_step: "
  \<forall>pc frs. 
  (exec_instr i G hp0 os0 lvars0 C S pc frs) = 
  (None, hp1, (os1,lvars1,C,S, Suc pc)#frs)
  \<Longrightarrow> {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- [i] \<rightarrow> {hp1, os1, lvars1}"
  apply (unfold progression_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply simp
  apply (rule exec_all_one_step)
    apply auto
  done

(*****)
definition jump_fwd :: "jvm_prog \<Rightarrow> cname \<Rightarrow> sig \<Rightarrow> 
                 aheap \<Rightarrow> locvars \<Rightarrow> opstack \<Rightarrow> opstack \<Rightarrow> 
                 instr \<Rightarrow> bytecode \<Rightarrow> bool" where
  "jump_fwd G C S hp lvars os0 os1 instr instrs ==
  \<forall>pre post frs.
  (gis (gmb G C S) = pre @ instr # instrs @ post) \<longrightarrow>
   exec_all G (None,hp,(os0,lvars,C,S, length pre)#frs)
    (None,hp,(os1,lvars,C,S,(length pre) + (length instrs) + 1)#frs)"


lemma jump_fwd_one_step:
  "\<forall>pc frs.
  exec_instr instr G hp os0 lvars C S pc frs = 
    (None, hp, (os1, lvars, C, S, pc + (length instrs) + 1)#frs)
  \<Longrightarrow> jump_fwd G C S hp lvars os0 os1 instr instrs"
  apply (unfold jump_fwd_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (rule exec_instr_in_exec_all)
   apply auto
  done


lemma jump_fwd_progression_aux: 
  "\<lbrakk> instrs_comb = instr # instrs0 @ instrs1; 
     jump_fwd G C S hp lvars os0 os1 instr instrs0;
     {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp, os1, lvars} >- instrs1 \<rightarrow> {hp2, os2, lvars2} \<rbrakk> 
  \<Longrightarrow> {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp, os0, lvars} >- instrs_comb \<rightarrow> {hp2, os2, lvars2}"
  apply (simp only: progression_def jump_fwd_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (rule_tac ?s1.0 = "Norm(hp, (os1, lvars, C, S, length pre + length instrs0 + 1) # frs)" in exec_all_trans)
   apply (simp only: append_assoc)
   apply (subgoal_tac "pre @ (instr # instrs0 @ instrs1) @ post = pre @ instr # instrs0 @ (instrs1 @ post)")
    apply blast
   apply simp
  apply (erule thin_rl, erule thin_rl)
  apply (drule_tac x="pre @ instr # instrs0" in spec)
  apply (simp add: add.assoc)
  done


lemma jump_fwd_progression:
  "\<lbrakk> instrs_comb = instr # instrs0 @ instrs1; 
  \<forall> pc frs.
  exec_instr instr G hp os0 lvars C S pc frs = 
    (None, hp, (os1, lvars, C, S, pc + (length instrs0) + 1)#frs);
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp, os1, lvars} >- instrs1 \<rightarrow> {hp2, os2, lvars2} \<rbrakk> 
  \<Longrightarrow> {G, C, S}  \<turnstile> {hp, os0, lvars} >- instrs_comb \<rightarrow> {hp2, os2, lvars2}"
  apply (rule jump_fwd_progression_aux)
    apply assumption
   apply (rule jump_fwd_one_step, assumption+)
  done


(* note: instrs and instr reversed wrt. jump_fwd *)
definition jump_bwd :: "jvm_prog \<Rightarrow> cname \<Rightarrow> sig \<Rightarrow> 
                 aheap \<Rightarrow> locvars \<Rightarrow> opstack \<Rightarrow> opstack \<Rightarrow> 
                 bytecode \<Rightarrow> instr \<Rightarrow> bool" where
  "jump_bwd G C S hp lvars os0 os1 instrs instr ==
  \<forall> pre post frs.
  (gis (gmb G C S) = pre @ instrs @ instr # post) \<longrightarrow>
   exec_all G (None,hp,(os0,lvars,C,S, (length pre) + (length instrs))#frs)
    (None,hp,(os1,lvars,C,S, (length pre))#frs)"


lemma jump_bwd_one_step:
  "\<forall> pc frs.
  exec_instr instr G hp os0 lvars C S (pc + (length instrs)) frs = 
    (None, hp, (os1, lvars, C, S, pc)#frs)
  \<Longrightarrow> 
  jump_bwd G C S hp lvars os0 os1 instrs instr"
  apply (unfold jump_bwd_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (rule exec_instr_in_exec_all)
   apply auto
  done

lemma jump_bwd_progression: 
  "\<lbrakk> instrs_comb = instrs @ [instr]; 
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- instrs \<rightarrow> {hp1, os1, lvars1};
  jump_bwd G C S hp1 lvars1 os1 os2 instrs instr;
  {G, C, S} \<turnstile> {hp1, os2, lvars1} >- instrs_comb \<rightarrow> {hp3, os3, lvars3} \<rbrakk> 
  \<Longrightarrow> {G, C, S}  \<turnstile> {hp0, os0, lvars0} >- instrs_comb \<rightarrow> {hp3, os3, lvars3}"
  apply (simp only: progression_def jump_bwd_def)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (rule exec_all_trans, force)
  apply (rule exec_all_trans, force)
  apply (rule exec_all_trans, force)
  apply simp
  apply (rule exec_all_refl)
  done


(**********************************************************************)

(* class C with signature S is defined in program G *)
definition class_sig_defined :: "'c prog \<Rightarrow> cname \<Rightarrow> sig \<Rightarrow> bool" where
  "class_sig_defined G C S == 
  is_class G C \<and> (\<exists> D rT mb. (method (G, C) S = Some (D, rT, mb)))"


(* The environment of a java method body 
  (characterized by class and signature) *)
definition env_of_jmb :: "java_mb prog \<Rightarrow> cname \<Rightarrow> sig \<Rightarrow> java_mb env" where
  "env_of_jmb G C S == 
  (let (mn,pTs) = S;
       (D,rT,(pns,lvars,blk,res)) = the(method (G, C) S) in
  (G,(map_of lvars)(pns[\<mapsto>]pTs, This\<mapsto>Class C)))"

lemma env_of_jmb_fst [simp]: "fst (env_of_jmb G C S) = G"
by (simp add: env_of_jmb_def split_beta)


(**********************************************************************)


lemma method_preserves [rule_format (no_asm)]:
  "\<lbrakk> wf_prog wf_mb G; is_class G C; 
  \<forall> S rT mb. \<forall> cn \<in> fst ` set G. wf_mdecl wf_mb G cn (S,rT,mb)  \<longrightarrow> (P cn S (rT,mb))\<rbrakk>
 \<Longrightarrow> \<forall> D. 
  method (G, C) S = Some (D, rT, mb) \<longrightarrow> (P D S (rT,mb))"

  apply (frule wf_prog_ws_prog [THEN wf_subcls1])
  apply (rule subcls1_induct, assumption, assumption)

   apply (intro strip)
   apply ((drule spec)+, drule_tac x="Object" in bspec)
    apply (simp add: wf_prog_def ws_prog_def wf_syscls_def)
   apply (subgoal_tac "D=Object") apply simp
    apply (drule mp)
     apply (frule_tac C=Object in method_wf_mdecl)
       apply simp
      apply assumption
     apply simp
    apply assumption
   apply simp

  apply (simplesubst method_rec)
    apply simp
   apply force
  apply simp
  apply (simp only: map_add_def)
  apply (split option.split)
  apply (rule conjI)
   apply force
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (frule_tac ?P1.0 = "wf_mdecl wf_mb G Ca" and
                   ?P2.0 = "%(S, (Da, rT, mb)). P Da S (rT, mb)" in map_of_map_prop)
    apply (force simp: wf_cdecl_def)

   apply clarify

   apply (simp only: class_def)
   apply (drule map_of_SomeD)+
   apply (frule_tac A="set G" and f=fst in imageI, simp)
   apply blast
  apply simp
  done


lemma method_preserves_length:
  "\<lbrakk> wf_java_prog G; is_class G C; 
  method (G, C) (mn,pTs) = Some (D, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res)\<rbrakk>
 \<Longrightarrow> length pns = length pTs"
  apply (frule_tac P="%D (mn,pTs) (rT, pns, lvars, blk, res). length pns = length pTs"
                   in method_preserves)
  apply (auto simp: wf_mdecl_def wf_java_mdecl_def)
  done

(**********************************************************************)

definition wtpd_expr :: "java_mb env \<Rightarrow> expr \<Rightarrow> bool" where
  "wtpd_expr E e == (\<exists> T. E\<turnstile>e :: T)"

definition wtpd_exprs :: "java_mb env \<Rightarrow> (expr list) \<Rightarrow> bool" where
  "wtpd_exprs E e == (\<exists> T. E\<turnstile>e [::] T)"

definition wtpd_stmt :: "java_mb env \<Rightarrow> stmt \<Rightarrow> bool" where
  "wtpd_stmt E c == (E\<turnstile>c \<surd>)"

lemma wtpd_expr_newc: "wtpd_expr E (NewC C) \<Longrightarrow> is_class (prg E) C"
  by (simp only: wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_expr.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_expr_cast: "wtpd_expr E (Cast cn e) \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E e)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_expr.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_expr_lacc:
  "\<lbrakk> wtpd_expr (env_of_jmb G C S) (LAcc vn); class_sig_defined G C S \<rbrakk>
  \<Longrightarrow> vn \<in> set (gjmb_plns (gmb G C S)) \<or> vn = This"
  apply (clarsimp simp: wtpd_expr_def env_of_jmb_def class_sig_defined_def galldefs)
  apply (case_tac S)
  apply (erule ty_expr.cases; fastforce dest: map_upds_SomeD map_of_SomeD fst_in_set_lemma)
  done

lemma wtpd_expr_lass: "wtpd_expr E (vn::=e)
  \<Longrightarrow> (vn \<noteq> This) & (wtpd_expr E (LAcc vn)) & (wtpd_expr E e)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_expr.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_expr_facc: "wtpd_expr E ({fd}a..fn) 
  \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E a)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_expr.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_expr_fass: "wtpd_expr E ({fd}a..fn:=v) 
  \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E ({fd}a..fn)) & (wtpd_expr E v)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_expr.cases, auto)


lemma wtpd_expr_binop: "wtpd_expr E (BinOp bop e1 e2)
  \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E e1) & (wtpd_expr E e2)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_expr.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_exprs_cons: "wtpd_exprs E (e # es)
  \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E e) & (wtpd_exprs E es)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_exprs_def wtpd_expr_def, erule exE, erule ty_exprs.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_stmt_expr: "wtpd_stmt E (Expr e) \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E e)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_stmt_def wtpd_expr_def, erule wt_stmt.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_stmt_comp: "wtpd_stmt E (s1;; s2) \<Longrightarrow> 
   (wtpd_stmt E s1) &  (wtpd_stmt E s2)"
   by (simp only: wtpd_stmt_def wtpd_expr_def, erule wt_stmt.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_stmt_cond: "wtpd_stmt E (If(e) s1 Else s2) \<Longrightarrow>
   (wtpd_expr E e) & (wtpd_stmt E s1) &  (wtpd_stmt E s2)
  & (E\<turnstile>e::PrimT Boolean)"
  by (simp only: wtpd_stmt_def wtpd_expr_def, erule wt_stmt.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_stmt_loop: "wtpd_stmt E (While(e) s) \<Longrightarrow>
   (wtpd_expr E e) & (wtpd_stmt E s) & (E\<turnstile>e::PrimT Boolean)"
   by (simp only: wtpd_stmt_def wtpd_expr_def, erule wt_stmt.cases, auto)

lemma wtpd_expr_call: "wtpd_expr E ({C}a..mn({pTs'}ps))
  \<Longrightarrow> (wtpd_expr E a) & (wtpd_exprs E ps) 
  & (length ps = length pTs') & (E\<turnstile>a::Class C)
  & (\<exists> pTs md rT. 
       E\<turnstile>ps[::]pTs & max_spec (prg E) C (mn, pTs) = {((md,rT),pTs')})"
  apply (simp only: wtpd_expr_def wtpd_exprs_def)
  apply (erule exE)
  apply (ind_cases "E \<turnstile> {C}a..mn( {pTs'}ps) :: T" for T)
  apply (auto simp: max_spec_preserves_length)
  done

lemma wtpd_blk: 
  "\<lbrakk> method (G, D) (md, pTs) = Some (D, rT, (pns, lvars, blk, res)); 
  wf_prog wf_java_mdecl G; is_class G D \<rbrakk>
 \<Longrightarrow> wtpd_stmt (env_of_jmb G D (md, pTs)) blk"
  apply (simp add: wtpd_stmt_def env_of_jmb_def)
  apply (frule_tac P="%D (md, pTs) (rT, (pns, lvars, blk, res)). (G, (map_of lvars)(pns[\<mapsto>]pTs, This\<mapsto>Class D)) \<turnstile> blk \<surd> " in method_preserves)
     apply (auto simp: wf_mdecl_def wf_java_mdecl_def)
  done

lemma wtpd_res: 
  "\<lbrakk> method (G, D) (md, pTs) = Some (D, rT, (pns, lvars, blk, res)); 
  wf_prog wf_java_mdecl G; is_class G D \<rbrakk>
 \<Longrightarrow> wtpd_expr (env_of_jmb G D (md, pTs)) res"
  apply (simp add: wtpd_expr_def env_of_jmb_def)
  apply (frule_tac P="%D (md, pTs) (rT, (pns, lvars, blk, res)). \<exists>T. (G, (map_of lvars)(pns[\<mapsto>]pTs, This\<mapsto>Class D)) \<turnstile> res :: T " in method_preserves)
     apply (auto simp: wf_mdecl_def wf_java_mdecl_def)
  done


(**********************************************************************)


(* Is there a more elegant proof? *)
lemma evals_preserves_length:
  "G\<turnstile> xs -es[\<succ>]vs-> (None, s) \<Longrightarrow> length es = length vs"
  apply (subgoal_tac 
    "\<forall> xs'. (G \<turnstile> xk -xj\<succ>xi-> xh \<longrightarrow> True) & 
    (G\<turnstile> xs -es[\<succ>]vs-> xs' \<longrightarrow>  (\<exists> s. (xs' = (None, s))) \<longrightarrow> 
    length es = length vs) &
    (G \<turnstile> xc -xb-> xa \<longrightarrow> True)")
   apply blast
  apply (rule allI)
  apply (rule Eval.eval_evals_exec.induct; simp)
  done

(***********************************************************************)

(* required for translation of BinOp *)


lemma progression_Eq : "{G, C, S} \<turnstile>
  {hp, (v2 # v1 # os), lvars} 
  >- [Ifcmpeq 3, LitPush (Bool False), Goto 2, LitPush (Bool True)] \<rightarrow>
  {hp, (Bool (v1 = v2) # os), lvars}"
  apply (case_tac "v1 = v2")

   (* case v1 = v2 *)
   apply (rule_tac ?instrs1.0 = "[LitPush (Bool True)]" in jump_fwd_progression)
     apply (auto simp: nat_add_distrib)
   apply (rule progression_one_step)
   apply simp

  (* case v1 \<noteq> v2 *)
  apply (rule progression_one_step [THEN HOL.refl [THEN progression_transitive], simplified])
   apply auto
  apply (rule progression_one_step [THEN HOL.refl [THEN progression_transitive], simplified])
   apply auto
  apply (rule_tac ?instrs1.0 = "[]" in jump_fwd_progression)
    apply (auto simp: nat_add_distrib intro: progression_refl)
  done


(**********************************************************************)


(* to avoid automatic pair splits *)

declare split_paired_All [simp del] split_paired_Ex [simp del]

lemma distinct_method:
  "\<lbrakk> wf_java_prog G; is_class G C; method (G, C) S = Some (D, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res) \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> 
  distinct (gjmb_plns (gmb G C S))"
  apply (frule method_wf_mdecl [THEN conjunct2],  assumption, assumption)
  apply (case_tac S)
  apply (simp add: wf_mdecl_def wf_java_mdecl_def galldefs)
  apply (simp add: unique_def map_of_in_set)
  apply blast
  done

lemma distinct_method_if_class_sig_defined : 
  "\<lbrakk> wf_java_prog G; class_sig_defined G C S \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> distinct (gjmb_plns (gmb G C S))"
  by (auto intro: distinct_method simp: class_sig_defined_def)


lemma method_yields_wf_java_mdecl: "\<lbrakk> wf_java_prog G; is_class G C;
  method (G, C) S = Some (D, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res) \<rbrakk>  \<Longrightarrow> 
  wf_java_mdecl G D (S,rT,(pns,lvars,blk,res))"
  apply (frule method_wf_mdecl)
    apply (auto simp: wf_mdecl_def)
  done

(**********************************************************************)


lemma progression_lvar_init_aux [rule_format (no_asm)]: "
  \<forall> zs prfx lvals lvars0. 
  lvars0 =  (zs @ lvars) \<longrightarrow>
  (disjoint_varnames pns lvars0 \<longrightarrow>
  (length lvars = length lvals) \<longrightarrow> 
  (Suc(length pns + length zs) = length prfx) \<longrightarrow> 
   ({cG, D, S} \<turnstile> 
    {h, os, (prfx @ lvals)}
    >- (concat (map (compInit (pns, lvars0, blk, res)) lvars)) \<rightarrow>
    {h, os, (prfx @ (map (\<lambda>p. (default_val (snd p))) lvars))}))"
  apply simp
  apply (induct lvars)
   apply (clarsimp, rule progression_refl)
  apply (intro strip)
  apply (case_tac lvals)
   apply simp
  apply (simp (no_asm_simp) )

  apply (rule_tac ?lvars1.0 = "(prfx @ [default_val (snd a)]) @ list" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
   apply (case_tac a)
   apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: compInit_def)
   apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[load_default_val b]" in progression_transitive, simp)
    apply (rule progression_one_step)
    apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: load_default_val_def)

   apply (rule progression_one_step)
   apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
   apply (rule conjI, simp)+
   apply (simp add: index_of_var2)
  apply (drule_tac x="zs @ [a]" in spec) (* instantiate zs *)
  apply (drule mp, simp)
  apply (drule_tac x="(prfx @ [default_val (snd a)])" in spec) (* instantiate prfx *)
  apply auto
  done

lemma progression_lvar_init [rule_format (no_asm)]: 
  "\<lbrakk> wf_java_prog G; is_class G C;
  method (G, C) S = Some (D, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res) \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> 
  length pns = length pvs \<longrightarrow> 
  (\<forall> lvals. 
  length lvars = length lvals \<longrightarrow>
   {cG, D, S} \<turnstile>
   {h, os, (a' # pvs @ lvals)}
   >- (compInitLvars (pns, lvars, blk, res) lvars) \<rightarrow>
   {h, os, (locvars_xstate G C S (Norm (h, (init_vars lvars)(pns[\<mapsto>]pvs, This\<mapsto>a'))))})"
  apply (simp only: compInitLvars_def)
  apply (frule method_yields_wf_java_mdecl, assumption, assumption)

  apply (simp only: wf_java_mdecl_def)
  apply (subgoal_tac "(\<forall>y\<in>set pns. y \<notin> set (map fst lvars))")
   apply (simp add: init_vars_def locvars_xstate_def locvars_locals_def galldefs unique_def split_def map_of_map_as_map_upd del: map_map)
   apply (intro strip)
   apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: append_Cons [symmetric])
   apply (rule progression_lvar_init_aux)
      apply (auto simp: unique_def map_of_in_set disjoint_varnames_def)
  done




(**********************************************************************)

lemma state_ok_eval:
  "\<lbrakk>xs::\<preceq>E; wf_java_prog (prg E); wtpd_expr E e; (prg E)\<turnstile>xs -e\<succ>v -> xs'\<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow>  xs'::\<preceq>E"
  apply (simp only: wtpd_expr_def)
  apply (erule exE)
  apply (case_tac xs', case_tac xs)
  apply (auto intro: eval_type_sound [THEN conjunct1])
  done

lemma state_ok_evals:
  "\<lbrakk>xs::\<preceq>E; wf_java_prog (prg E); wtpd_exprs E es; prg E \<turnstile> xs -es[\<succ>]vs-> xs'\<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> xs'::\<preceq>E"
  apply (simp only: wtpd_exprs_def)
  apply (erule exE)
  apply (case_tac xs)
  apply (case_tac xs')
  apply (auto intro: evals_type_sound [THEN conjunct1])
  done

lemma state_ok_exec:
  "\<lbrakk>xs::\<preceq>E; wf_java_prog (prg E); wtpd_stmt E st; prg E \<turnstile> xs -st-> xs'\<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow>  xs'::\<preceq>E"
  apply (simp only: wtpd_stmt_def)
  apply (case_tac xs', case_tac xs)
  apply (auto dest: exec_type_sound)
  done

lemma state_ok_init: 
  "\<lbrakk> wf_java_prog G; (x, h, l)::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G C S); 
  is_class G dynT;
  method (G, dynT) (mn, pTs) = Some (md, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res);
  list_all2 (conf G h) pvs pTs; G,h \<turnstile> a' ::\<preceq> Class md\<rbrakk>
  \<Longrightarrow>
  (np a' x, h, (init_vars lvars)(pns[\<mapsto>]pvs, This\<mapsto>a'))::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G md (mn, pTs))"
  apply (frule wf_prog_ws_prog)
  apply (frule method_in_md [THEN conjunct2], assumption+)
  apply (frule method_yields_wf_java_mdecl, assumption, assumption)
  apply (simp add: env_of_jmb_def gs_def conforms_def split_beta)
  apply (simp add: wf_java_mdecl_def)
  apply (rule conjI)
   apply (rule lconf_ext)
    apply (rule lconf_ext_list)
       apply (rule lconf_init_vars)
       apply (auto dest: Ball_set_table)
  apply (simp add: np_def xconf_raise_if)
  done


lemma ty_exprs_list_all2 [rule_format (no_asm)]: 
  "(\<forall> Ts. (E \<turnstile> es [::] Ts) = list_all2 (\<lambda>e T. E \<turnstile> e :: T) es Ts)"
  apply (rule list.induct)
   apply simp
   apply (rule allI)
   apply (rule iffI)
    apply (ind_cases "E \<turnstile> [] [::] Ts" for Ts, assumption)
   apply simp apply (rule WellType.Nil)
  apply (simp add: list_all2_Cons1)
  apply (rule allI)
  apply (rule iffI)
   apply (rename_tac a exs Ts)
   apply (ind_cases "E \<turnstile> a # exs  [::] Ts" for a exs Ts) apply blast
  apply (auto intro: WellType.Cons)
  done


lemma conf_bool: "G,h \<turnstile> v::\<preceq>PrimT Boolean \<Longrightarrow> \<exists> b. v = Bool b"
  apply (simp add: conf_def)
  apply (erule exE)
  apply (case_tac v)
      apply (auto elim: widen.cases)
  done


lemma max_spec_widen: "max_spec G C (mn, pTs) = {((md,rT),pTs')} \<Longrightarrow> 
  list_all2 (\<lambda> T T'. G \<turnstile> T \<preceq> T') pTs pTs'"
  by (blast dest: singleton_in_set max_spec2appl_meths appl_methsD)


lemma eval_conf: "\<lbrakk>G \<turnstile> s -e\<succ>v-> s'; wf_java_prog G; s::\<preceq>E;
  E\<turnstile>e::T; gx s' = None; prg E = G \<rbrakk> 
  \<Longrightarrow> G,gh s'\<turnstile>v::\<preceq>T"
  apply (simp add: gh_def)
  apply (rule_tac x3="fst s" and s3="snd s"and x'3="fst s'"
               in eval_type_sound [THEN conjunct2 [THEN conjunct1 [THEN mp]], simplified])
       apply assumption+
      apply (simp (no_asm_use))
     apply (simp only: surjective_pairing [symmetric])
    apply (auto simp add: gs_def gx_def)
  done

lemma evals_preserves_conf:
  "\<lbrakk> G\<turnstile> s -es[\<succ>]vs-> s'; G,gh s \<turnstile> t ::\<preceq> T; E \<turnstile>es[::]Ts;
  wf_java_prog G; s::\<preceq>E; 
  prg E = G \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> G,gh s' \<turnstile> t ::\<preceq> T"
  apply (subgoal_tac "gh s\<le>| gh s'")
   apply (frule conf_hext, assumption, assumption)
  apply (frule eval_evals_exec_type_sound [THEN conjunct2 [THEN conjunct1 [THEN mp]]])
   apply (subgoal_tac "G \<turnstile> (gx s, (gh s, gl s)) -es[\<succ>]vs-> (gx s', (gh s', gl s'))")
    apply assumption
   apply (simp add: gx_def gh_def gl_def)
  apply (case_tac E)
  apply (simp add: gx_def gs_def gh_def gl_def)
  done

lemma eval_of_class:
  "\<lbrakk> G \<turnstile> s -e\<succ>a'-> s'; E \<turnstile> e :: Class C; wf_java_prog G; s::\<preceq>E; gx s'=None; a' \<noteq> Null; G=prg E\<rbrakk>
  \<Longrightarrow> (\<exists> lc. a' = Addr lc)"
  apply (case_tac s, case_tac s', simp)
  apply (frule eval_type_sound, (simp add: gs_def)+)
  apply (case_tac a')
      apply (auto simp: conf_def)
  done


lemma dynT_subcls: 
  "\<lbrakk> a' \<noteq> Null; G,h\<turnstile>a'::\<preceq> Class C; dynT = fst (the (h (the_Addr a')));
  is_class G dynT; ws_prog G \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow> G\<turnstile>dynT \<preceq>C C"
  apply (case_tac "C = Object")
   apply (simp, rule subcls_C_Object, assumption+)
  apply simp
  apply (frule non_np_objD, auto)
  done


lemma method_defined: "\<lbrakk> 
  m = the (method (G, dynT) (mn, pTs)); 
  dynT = fst (the (h a)); is_class G dynT; wf_java_prog G; 
  a' \<noteq> Null; G,h\<turnstile>a'::\<preceq> Class C; a = the_Addr a';
  \<exists>pTsa md rT. max_spec G C (mn, pTsa) = {((md, rT), pTs)} \<rbrakk>
\<Longrightarrow> (method (G, dynT) (mn, pTs)) = Some m"
  apply (erule exE)+
  apply (drule singleton_in_set, drule max_spec2appl_meths)
  apply (simp add: appl_methds_def)
  apply (elim exE conjE)
  apply (drule widen_methd)
  apply (auto intro!: dynT_subcls)
  done



(**********************************************************************)


(* 1. any difference between locvars_xstate \<dots> and L ??? *)
(* 2. possibly skip env_of_jmb ??? *)
theorem compiler_correctness: 
  "wf_java_prog G \<Longrightarrow>
  (G \<turnstile> xs -ex\<succ>val-> xs' \<longrightarrow>
  gx xs = None \<longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<longrightarrow>
  (\<forall> os CL S.
  (class_sig_defined G CL S) \<longrightarrow> 
  (wtpd_expr (env_of_jmb G CL S) ex) \<longrightarrow>
  (xs ::\<preceq> (env_of_jmb G CL S)) \<longrightarrow>
  ( {TranslComp.comp G, CL, S} \<turnstile>
    {gh xs, os, (locvars_xstate G CL S xs)}
    >- (compExpr (gmb G CL S) ex) \<rightarrow>
    {gh xs', val#os, locvars_xstate G CL S xs'}))) \<and> 

 (G \<turnstile> xs -exs[\<succ>]vals-> xs' \<longrightarrow>
  gx xs = None \<longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<longrightarrow>
  (\<forall> os CL S.
  (class_sig_defined G CL S) \<longrightarrow> 
  (wtpd_exprs (env_of_jmb G CL S) exs) \<longrightarrow>
  (xs::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G CL S)) \<longrightarrow>
  ( {TranslComp.comp G, CL, S} \<turnstile>
    {gh xs, os, (locvars_xstate G CL S xs)}
    >- (compExprs (gmb G CL S) exs) \<rightarrow>
    {gh xs', (rev vals)@os, (locvars_xstate G CL S xs')}))) \<and> 

  (G \<turnstile> xs -st-> xs' \<longrightarrow>
   gx xs = None \<longrightarrow> gx xs' = None \<longrightarrow>
  (\<forall> os CL S.
  (class_sig_defined G CL S) \<longrightarrow> 
  (wtpd_stmt (env_of_jmb G CL S) st) \<longrightarrow>
  (xs::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G CL S)) \<longrightarrow>
  ( {TranslComp.comp G, CL, S} \<turnstile>
    {gh xs, os, (locvars_xstate G CL S xs)}
    >- (compStmt (gmb G CL S) st) \<rightarrow>
    {gh xs', os, (locvars_xstate G CL S xs')})))"
  apply (rule Eval.eval_evals_exec.induct)

                     (* case XcptE *)
                     apply simp

                    (* case NewC *)
                    apply clarify
                    apply (frule wf_prog_ws_prog [THEN wf_subcls1]) (* establish  wf ((subcls1 G)\<inverse>) *)
                    apply (simp add: c_hupd_hp_invariant)
                    apply (rule progression_one_step)
                    apply (rotate_tac 1, drule sym) (* reverse equation (a, None) = new_Addr (fst s) *)
                    apply (simp add: locvars_xstate_def locvars_locals_def comp_fields)


                   (* case Cast *)
                   apply (intro allI impI)
                   apply simp
                   apply (frule raise_if_NoneD)
                   apply (frule wtpd_expr_cast)
                   apply simp
                   apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e)" in progression_transitive, simp)
                    apply blast
                   apply (rule progression_one_step)
                   apply (simp add: raise_system_xcpt_def  gh_def comp_cast_ok)


                  (* case Lit *)
                  apply simp
                  apply (intro strip)
                  apply (rule progression_one_step)
                  apply simp


                 (* case BinOp *)
                 apply (intro allI impI)
                 apply (frule_tac xs=s1 in eval_xcpt, assumption) (* establish (gx s1 = None) *)
                 apply (frule wtpd_expr_binop)
                 (* establish (s1::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
                 apply (frule_tac e=e1 in state_ok_eval) apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
                   apply simp
                  apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)


                 apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: compExpr.simps compExprs.simps)
                 apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compExpr (gmb G CL S) e1" in progression_transitive, simp) apply blast
                 apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compExpr (gmb G CL S) e2" in progression_transitive, simp) apply blast
                 apply (case_tac bop)
                  (*subcase bop = Eq *)
                  apply simp
                  apply (rule progression_Eq)
                 (*subcase bop = Add *)
                 apply simp
                 apply (rule progression_one_step)
                 apply simp


                (* case LAcc *)
                apply simp
                apply (intro strip)
                apply (rule progression_one_step)
                apply (simp add: locvars_xstate_def locvars_locals_def)
                apply (frule wtpd_expr_lacc)
                 apply assumption
                apply (simp add: gl_def)
                apply (erule select_at_index)


               (* case LAss *)
               apply (intro allI impI)
               apply (frule wtpd_expr_lass, erule conjE, erule conjE)
               apply simp

               apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
                apply blast

               apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[Dup]" in progression_transitive, simp)
                apply (rule progression_one_step)
                apply (simp add: gh_def)
               apply simp
               apply (rule progression_one_step)
               apply (simp add: gh_def)
               (* the following falls out of the general scheme *)
               apply (frule wtpd_expr_lacc) apply assumption
               apply (rule update_at_index)
                 apply (rule distinct_method_if_class_sig_defined)
                  apply assumption
                 apply assumption
                apply simp
               apply assumption


              (* case FAcc *)
              apply (intro allI impI)
              (* establish x1 = None \<and> a' \<noteq> Null *)
              apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: gx_conv, frule np_NoneD)
              apply (frule wtpd_expr_facc)

              apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: compExpr.simps compExprs.simps)
              apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
               apply blast
              apply (rule progression_one_step)
              apply (simp add: gh_def)
              apply (case_tac "(the (fst s1 (the_Addr a')))")
              apply (simp add: raise_system_xcpt_def)


             (* case FAss *)
             apply (intro allI impI)
             apply (frule wtpd_expr_fass) apply (erule conjE) apply (frule wtpd_expr_facc)
             apply (simp only: c_hupd_xcpt_invariant) (* establish x2 = None *)
             (* establish x1 = None  and  a' \<noteq> Null  *)
             apply (frule_tac xs="(np a' x1, s1)" in eval_xcpt)
              apply (simp only: gx_conv, simp only: gx_conv, frule np_NoneD, erule conjE)


             (* establish ((Norm s1)::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
             apply (frule_tac e=e1 in state_ok_eval)
                apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
               apply assumption
              apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)

             apply (simp only: compExpr.simps compExprs.simps)

             apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e1)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
              apply fast (* blast does not seem to work - why? *)
             apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e2)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
              apply fast
             apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[Dup_x1]" and ?instrs1.0 = "[Putfield fn T]" in progression_transitive, simp)

              (* Dup_x1 *)
              apply (rule progression_one_step)
              apply (simp add: gh_def)

             (* Putfield \<longrightarrow> still looks nasty*)
             apply (rule progression_one_step)
             apply simp
             apply (case_tac "(the (fst s2 (the_Addr a')))")
             apply (simp add: c_hupd_hp_invariant)
             apply (case_tac s2)
             apply (simp add: c_hupd_conv raise_system_xcpt_def)
             apply (rule locvars_xstate_par_dep, rule HOL.refl)

            defer (* method call *)

            (* case XcptEs *)
            apply simp

           (* case Nil *)
           apply simp
           apply (intro strip)
           apply (rule progression_refl)

          (* case Cons *)
          apply (intro allI impI)
          apply (frule_tac xs=s1 in evals_xcpt, simp only: gx_conv) (* establish gx s1 = None *)
          apply (frule wtpd_exprs_cons)
          (* establish ((Norm s0)::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
          apply (frule_tac e=e in state_ok_eval)
             apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
            apply simp
           apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)

          apply simp
          apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
           apply fast
          apply fast


         (* case Statement: exception *)
         apply simp

        (* case Skip *)
        apply (intro allI impI)
        apply simp
        apply (rule progression_refl)

       (* case Expr *)
       apply (intro allI impI)
       apply (frule wtpd_stmt_expr)
       apply simp
       apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
        apply fast
       apply (rule progression_one_step)
       apply simp

      (* case Comp *)
      apply (intro allI impI)
      apply (frule_tac xs=s1 in exec_xcpt, assumption) (* establish (gx s1 = None) *)
      apply (frule wtpd_stmt_comp)

      (* establish (s1::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
      apply (frule_tac st=c1 in state_ok_exec)
         apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
        apply simp apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)

      apply simp
      apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compStmt (gmb G CL S) c1)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
       apply fast
      apply fast


     (* case Cond *)
     apply (intro allI impI)
     apply (frule_tac xs=s1 in exec_xcpt, assumption) (* establish (gx s1 = None) *)
     apply (frule wtpd_stmt_cond, (erule conjE)+)
     (* establish (s1::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
     apply (frule_tac e=e in state_ok_eval)
        apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
       apply assumption
      apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
     (* establish G,gh s1\<turnstile>v::\<preceq>PrimT Boolean *)
     apply (frule eval_conf, assumption+, rule env_of_jmb_fst)
     apply (frule conf_bool) (* establish \<exists>b. v = Bool b *)
     apply (erule exE)

     apply simp
     apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[LitPush (Bool False)]" in progression_transitive, simp (no_asm_simp))
      apply (rule progression_one_step,  simp)

     apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compExpr (gmb G CL S) e" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
      apply fast

     apply (case_tac b)
      (* case b= True *)
      apply simp
      apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[Ifcmpeq (2 + int (length (compStmt (gmb G CL S) c1)))]" in progression_transitive, simp)
       apply (rule progression_one_step)
       apply simp
      apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compStmt (gmb G CL S) c1)" in progression_transitive, simp)
       apply fast
      apply (rule_tac ?instrs1.0 = "[]" in jump_fwd_progression)
        apply (simp)
       apply simp
       apply (rule conjI, simp)
       apply (simp add: nat_add_distrib)
      apply (rule progression_refl)

     (* case b= False *)
     apply simp
     apply (rule_tac ?instrs1.0 = "compStmt (gmb G CL S) c2" in jump_fwd_progression)
       apply (simp)
      apply (simp, rule conjI, rule HOL.refl, simp add: nat_add_distrib)
     apply fast

    (* case exit Loop *)
    apply (intro allI impI)
    apply (frule wtpd_stmt_loop, (erule conjE)+)

    (* establish G,gh s1\<turnstile>v::\<preceq>PrimT Boolean *)
    apply (frule eval_conf, assumption+, rule env_of_jmb_fst)
    apply (frule conf_bool) (* establish \<exists>b. v = Bool b *)
    apply (erule exE)
    apply (case_tac b)

     (* case b= True \<longrightarrow> contradiction *)
     apply simp

    (* case b= False *)
    apply simp

    apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[LitPush (Bool False)]" in progression_transitive, simp (no_asm_simp))
     apply (rule progression_one_step)
     apply simp

    apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compExpr (gmb G CL S) e" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
     apply fast
    apply (rule_tac ?instrs1.0 = "[]" in jump_fwd_progression)
      apply (simp)
     apply (simp, rule conjI, rule HOL.refl, simp add: nat_add_distrib)
    apply (rule progression_refl)


   (* case continue Loop *)
   apply (intro allI impI)
   apply (frule_tac xs=s2 in exec_xcpt, assumption) (* establish (gx s2 = None) *)
   apply (frule_tac xs=s1 in exec_xcpt, assumption) (* establish (gx s1 = None) *)
   apply (frule wtpd_stmt_loop, (erule conjE)+)

   (* establish (s1::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
   apply (frule_tac e=e in state_ok_eval)
      apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
     apply simp
    apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
   (* establish (s2::\<preceq> \<dots>) *)
   apply (frule_tac xs=s1 and st=c in state_ok_exec)
      apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
     apply assumption
    apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)

   (* establish G,gh s1\<turnstile>v::\<preceq>PrimT Boolean *)
   apply (frule eval_conf, assumption+, rule env_of_jmb_fst)
   apply (frule conf_bool) (* establish \<exists>b. v = Bool b *)
   apply (erule exE)

   apply simp
   apply (rule jump_bwd_progression)
      apply simp

     apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[LitPush (Bool False)]" in progression_transitive, simp (no_asm_simp))
      apply (rule progression_one_step)
      apply simp

     apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compExpr (gmb G CL S) e" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
      apply fast

     apply (case_tac b)
      (* case b= True *)
      apply simp

      apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "[Ifcmpeq (2 + int (length (compStmt (gmb G CL S) c)))]" in progression_transitive, simp)
       apply (rule progression_one_step)
       apply simp
      apply fast

     (* case b= False \<longrightarrow> contradiction*)
     apply simp

    apply (rule jump_bwd_one_step)
    apply simp
   apply blast

  (*****)
  (* case method call *)

  apply (intro allI impI)

  apply (frule_tac xs=s3 in eval_xcpt, simp only: gx_conv) (* establish gx s3 = None *)
  apply (frule exec_xcpt, assumption, simp (no_asm_use) only: gx_conv, frule np_NoneD) (* establish x = None \<and> a' \<noteq> Null *)
  apply (frule evals_xcpt, simp only: gx_conv) (* establish gx s1 = None *)

  apply (frule wtpd_expr_call, (erule conjE)+)


  (* assumptions about state_ok and is_class *)

  (* establish s1::\<preceq> (env_of_jmb G CL S) *)
  apply (frule_tac xs="Norm s0" and e=e in state_ok_eval)
     apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst, assumption, simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)

  (* establish (x, h, l)::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G CL S) *)
  apply (frule_tac xs=s1 and xs'="(x, h, l)" in state_ok_evals)
     apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst, assumption, simp only: env_of_jmb_fst)

  (* establish \<exists> lc. a' = Addr lc *)
  apply (frule (5) eval_of_class, rule env_of_jmb_fst [symmetric])
  apply (subgoal_tac "G,h \<turnstile> a' ::\<preceq> Class C")
   apply (subgoal_tac "is_class G dynT")

    (* establish method (G, dynT) (mn, pTs) = Some(md, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res) *)
    apply (drule method_defined, assumption+)
     apply (simp only: env_of_jmb_fst)
     apply ((erule exE)+, erule conjE, (rule exI)+, assumption)

    apply (subgoal_tac "is_class G md")
     apply (subgoal_tac "G\<turnstile>Class dynT \<preceq> Class md")
      apply (subgoal_tac " method (G, md) (mn, pTs) = Some (md, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res)")
       apply (subgoal_tac "list_all2 (conf G h) pvs pTs")

        (* establish (np a' x, h, init_vars lvars(pns[\<mapsto>]pvs)(This\<mapsto>a'))::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G md (mn, pTs)) *)
        apply (subgoal_tac "G,h \<turnstile> a' ::\<preceq> Class dynT")
         apply (frule (2) conf_widen)
         apply (frule state_ok_init, assumption+)

         apply (subgoal_tac "class_sig_defined G md (mn, pTs)")
          apply (frule wtpd_blk, assumption, assumption)
          apply (frule wtpd_res, assumption, assumption)
          apply (subgoal_tac "s3::\<preceq>(env_of_jmb G md (mn, pTs))")

           apply (subgoal_tac "method (TranslComp.comp G, md) (mn, pTs) =
                               Some (md, rT, snd (snd (compMethod G md ((mn, pTs), rT, pns, lvars, blk, res))))")
            prefer 2
            apply (simp add: wf_prog_ws_prog [THEN comp_method])
           apply (subgoal_tac "method (TranslComp.comp G, dynT) (mn, pTs) =
                               Some (md, rT, snd (snd (compMethod G md ((mn, pTs), rT, pns, lvars, blk, res))))")
            prefer 2
            apply (simp add: wf_prog_ws_prog [THEN comp_method])
           apply (simp only: fst_conv snd_conv)

           (* establish length pns = length pTs *)
           apply (frule method_preserves_length, assumption, assumption)
           (* establish length pvs = length ps *)
           apply (frule evals_preserves_length [symmetric])

           (** start evaluating subexpressions **)
           apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: compExpr.simps compExprs.simps)

           (* evaluate e *)
           apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compExpr (gmb G CL S) e)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
            apply fast

           (* evaluate parameters *)
           apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compExprs (gmb G CL S) ps" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
            apply fast

           (* invokation *)
           apply (rule progression_call)
           apply (intro allI impI conjI)
              (* execute Invoke statement *)
              apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: exec_instr.simps)
              apply (erule thin_rl, erule thin_rl, erule thin_rl)
              apply (simp add: compMethod_def raise_system_xcpt_def)

             (* get instructions of invoked method *)
             apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: gis_def gmb_def compMethod_def)

            (* var. initialization *)
            apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "(compInitLvars (pns, lvars, blk, res) lvars)" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
             apply (rule_tac C=md in progression_lvar_init, assumption, assumption, assumption)
              apply (simp (no_asm_simp)) (* length pns = length pvs *)
             apply (simp (no_asm_simp)) (* length lvars = length (replicate (length lvars) undefined) *)


            (* body statement *)
            apply (rule_tac ?instrs0.0 = "compStmt (pns, lvars, blk, res) blk" in progression_transitive, rule HOL.refl)
             apply (subgoal_tac "(pns, lvars, blk, res) = gmb G md (mn, pTs)")
              apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
              apply (simp only: gh_conv)
              apply (drule mp [OF _ TrueI])+
              apply (erule allE, erule allE, erule allE, erule impE, assumption)+
              apply ((erule impE, assumption)+, assumption)

             apply (simp (no_asm_use))
             apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: gmb_def)

            (* return expression *)
            apply (subgoal_tac "(pns, lvars, blk, res) = gmb G md (mn, pTs)")
             apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
             apply (simp only: gh_conv)
             apply ((drule mp, rule TrueI)+, (drule spec)+, (drule mp, assumption)+, assumption)
            apply (simp (no_asm_use))
            apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: gmb_def)

           (* execute return statement *)
           apply (simp (no_asm_use) add: gh_def locvars_xstate_def gl_def del: drop_append)
           apply (subgoal_tac "rev pvs @ a' # os = (rev (a' # pvs)) @ os")
            apply (simp only: drop_append)
            apply (simp (no_asm_simp))
           apply (simp (no_asm_simp))

          (* show s3::\<preceq>\<dots> *)
          apply (rule_tac xs = "(np a' x, h, (init_vars lvars)(pns[\<mapsto>]pvs, This\<mapsto>a'))" and st=blk in state_ok_exec)
             apply assumption
            apply (simp (no_asm_simp) only: env_of_jmb_fst)
           apply assumption
          apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: env_of_jmb_fst)

         (* show class_sig_defined G md (mn, pTs) *)
         apply (simp (no_asm_simp) add: class_sig_defined_def)

        (* show G,h \<turnstile> a' ::\<preceq> Class dynT *)
        apply (frule non_npD)
         apply assumption
        apply (erule exE)+
        apply simp
        apply (rule conf_obj_AddrI)
        apply simp
        apply (rule widen_Class_Class [THEN iffD1], rule widen.refl)


       (* show list_all2 (conf G h) pvs pTs *)
       apply (erule exE)+ apply (erule conjE)+
       apply (rule_tac Ts="pTsa" in conf_list_gext_widen)
         apply assumption
        apply (subgoal_tac "G \<turnstile> (gx s1, gs s1) -ps[\<succ>]pvs-> (x, h, l)")
         apply (frule_tac E="env_of_jmb G CL S" in evals_type_sound)
             apply assumption+
            apply (simp only: env_of_jmb_fst)
            apply (simp add: conforms_def xconf_def gs_def)
           apply simp
          apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: gx_def gs_def surjective_pairing [symmetric])
          apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: ty_exprs_list_all2)
          apply simp
         apply simp
        apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: gx_def gs_def surjective_pairing [symmetric])
       (* list_all2 (\<lambda>T T'. G \<turnstile> T \<preceq> T') pTsa pTs *)
       apply (rule max_spec_widen, simp only: env_of_jmb_fst)


      (* show method (G, md) (mn, pTs) = Some (md, rT, pns, lvars, blk, res) *)
      apply (frule wf_prog_ws_prog [THEN method_in_md [THEN conjunct2]], assumption+)

     (* show G\<turnstile>Class dynT \<preceq> Class md *)
     apply (simp (no_asm_use) only: widen_Class_Class)
     apply (rule method_wf_mdecl [THEN conjunct1], assumption+)

    (* is_class G md *)
    apply (rule wf_prog_ws_prog [THEN method_in_md [THEN conjunct1]], assumption+)

   (* show is_class G dynT *)
   apply (frule non_npD)
    apply assumption
   apply (erule exE)+
   apply (erule conjE)+
   apply simp
   apply (rule subcls_is_class2)
    apply assumption
   apply (frule expr_class_is_class [rotated])
    apply (simp only: env_of_jmb_fst)
    apply (rule wf_prog_ws_prog, assumption)
   apply (simp only: env_of_jmb_fst)

  (* show G,h \<turnstile> a' ::\<preceq> Class C *)
  apply (simp only: wtpd_exprs_def, erule exE)
  apply (frule evals_preserves_conf)
       apply (rule eval_conf, assumption+)
       apply (rule env_of_jmb_fst, assumption+)
   apply (rule env_of_jmb_fst)
  apply (simp only: gh_conv)
  done


theorem compiler_correctness_eval: "
  \<lbrakk> G \<turnstile> (None,hp,loc) -ex \<succ> val-> (None,hp',loc');
  wf_java_prog G;
  class_sig_defined G C S;
  wtpd_expr (env_of_jmb G C S) ex;
  (None,hp,loc) ::\<preceq> (env_of_jmb G C S) \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow>
  {(TranslComp.comp G), C, S} \<turnstile> 
    {hp, os, (locvars_locals G C S loc)}
      >- (compExpr (gmb G C S) ex) \<rightarrow> 
    {hp', val#os, (locvars_locals G C S loc')}"
  apply (frule compiler_correctness [THEN conjunct1])
  apply (auto simp: gh_def gx_def gs_def gl_def locvars_xstate_def)
  done

theorem compiler_correctness_exec: "
  \<lbrakk> G \<turnstile> Norm (hp, loc) -st-> Norm (hp', loc');
  wf_java_prog G;
  class_sig_defined G C S;
  wtpd_stmt (env_of_jmb G C S) st;
  (None,hp,loc) ::\<preceq> (env_of_jmb G C S) \<rbrakk> \<Longrightarrow>
  {(TranslComp.comp G), C, S} \<turnstile> 
    {hp, os, (locvars_locals G C S loc)}
      >- (compStmt (gmb G C S) st) \<rightarrow>
    {hp', os, (locvars_locals G C S loc')}"
  apply (frule compiler_correctness [THEN conjunct2 [THEN conjunct2]])
  apply (auto simp: gh_def gx_def gs_def gl_def locvars_xstate_def)
  done

(**********************************************************************)


(* reinstall pair splits *)
declare split_paired_All [simp] split_paired_Ex [simp]

declare wf_prog_ws_prog [simp del]

end